資料取得聲明：本報告所整理資料均由公開頁面及 LINE 官方帳號取得；調查未以不法方式入侵主機。

公開前端觀察報告 · 圖證與程式碼版

從報名到「直播」
畫面背後發生了什麼？

七組課程網站的銷售、等待、註冊與播放流程，以及 LINE 導向的新聞頁。每項觀察以頁面畫面、程式片段與結論範圍呈現。

報告建立日期：2026/11/3 · 資料保存：2026/11/1～11/2 · 補充查核：2026/11/2 · 時區 Asia/Taipei
畫面呈現限時報名、下一場直播、在線人數與觀眾留言
可確認的程式行為公式人數、動態場次、預錄分流與定時聊天腳本
最直接的證據集中在：報名人數公式、銷售頁 d 參數篩選場次、預錄連結分支、JIT 場次生成、預排聊天訊息及訪客編號避撞。人物身分與新聞獨立性則保留為待核疑點；報告不把「搜尋不到」寫成「不存在」。
銷售頁身分、價格、報名數等待頁星期、真人／預錄分流註冊頁JIT 場次與電話轉址直播頁影片、人數、聊天腳本新聞背書LINE、搜尋與舊活動
總覽

七組品牌總表

先看各品牌的講師標示、預錄連結與聊天室預排留言概況。

品牌講師／頁面標示是否有預錄是否有腳本留言
AICREATORChloe Chou／周心怡（素材註明為示意）未確認，沒有對應直播等待頁未確認，沒有對應直播室
ADragon六指淵（但銷售頁看不出來）有預錄預設連結；程式也保留真人分支目前看不出來；10/25 的直播場次有開啟聊天室，也有訪客
SalesKingVincent（直播有寫，但銷售頁看不出來）有預錄預設連結；程式也保留真人分支0 則
AI-NEXTAnna（頁面標示；身分未核實）有預錄預設連結；程式也保留真人分支83 則
AppIPO洪瑋岳（頁面主視覺標示）有預錄預設連結；程式也保留真人分支1 則
AI Plus／n8n六指淵有預錄預設連結；程式也保留真人分支225 則
AI First多位講師有預錄預設連結；程式也保留真人分支59 則
01

銷售頁

看品牌、身分、費用與報名前的揭露，哪些資訊能被獨立確認。

S1程式／保存畫面可確認

不同品牌網址，沿用相近頁面結構與追蹤系統

入口多採 form.品牌網域/?p=課程代碼，等待頁採 room.品牌網域/。六份銷售頁主程式在只統一品牌查詢設定後，正規化 SHA-256 完全相同；五份等待頁也各自一致。這支持共用建站系統，不能單憑它認定由同一家法定公司營運。

品牌 銷售頁
AICREATOR https://form.hipro.cc/?p=aicreator
ADragon https://form.adragon.cc/?p=p
SalesKing https://form.hipro.cc/?p=salesking
AI-NEXT https://form.ainext.pro/?p=ainext
AppIPO https://form.appipo.cc/?p=idea
AI Plus／n8n https://form.ai-plus.cc/?p=n8n
AI First https://form.ai-first.vip/?p=aifirst

保存樣本共用 GTM GTM-MZGCRQ2M；前六組瀏覽器記錄還出現 Google Ads AW-366361026。Meta 資料集 ID 則有品牌差異，不能說所有追蹤碼都相同。

ADragon 銷售頁

卡片、價格、倒數、報名按鈕的共同版型。

AI-NEXT 銷售頁

更換品牌、素材、課程代碼，沿用相同報名版型。

AI Plus／n8n 銷售頁

對照相同位置的報名資訊與按鈕。

原始碼證據 P01 共用 GTM 容器 
   1  (function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({'gtm.start':
   2  new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js'});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],
   3  j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';j.async=true;j.src=
   4  'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f);
   5  })(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-MZGCRQ2M');
設定證據 P02 正規化主程式雜湊比對 
{
  "form": [
    [
      "g1_form_AICREATOR",
      "6b576042c7cd4ed34d208010e41456b13a1fe4d9698393b02b0ee2ee17be0e2a"
    ],
    [
      "g2_form_adragon",
      "6b576042c7cd4ed34d208010e41456b13a1fe4d9698393b02b0ee2ee17be0e2a"
    ],
    [
      "g3_form_salesking",
      "6b576042c7cd4ed34d208010e41456b13a1fe4d9698393b02b0ee2ee17be0e2a"
    ],
    [
      "g4_form_ainext",
      "6b576042c7cd4ed34d208010e41456b13a1fe4d9698393b02b0ee2ee17be0e2a"
    ],
    [
      "g5_form_appipo",
      "6b576042c7cd4ed34d208010e41456b13a1fe4d9698393b02b0ee2ee17be0e2a"
    ],
    [
      "g6_form_n8n",
      "6b576042c7cd4ed34d208010e41456b13a1fe4d9698393b02b0ee2ee17be0e2a"
    ]
  ],
  "room": [
    [
      "g2_room_adragon",
      "bb289cc5b2cf5f207fd883a0d5f0c42b4b6bece405769e1f552fe937dbb6cfd1"
    ],
    [
      "g3_room_salesking",
      "bb289cc5b2cf5f207fd883a0d5f0c42b4b6bece405769e1f552fe937dbb6cfd1"
    ],
    [
      "g4_room_ainext",
      "bb289cc5b2cf5f207fd883a0d5f0c42b4b6bece405769e1f552fe937dbb6cfd1"
    ],
    [
      "g5_room_appipo",
      "bb289cc5b2cf5f207fd883a0d5f0c42b4b6bece405769e1f552fe937dbb6cfd1"
    ],
    [
      "g6_room_n8n",
      "bb289cc5b2cf5f207fd883a0d5f0c42b4b6bece405769e1f552fe937dbb6cfd1"
    ]
  ]
}
S7程式／現場選單可確認

銷售頁網址的 d= 可篩選報名視窗顯示的星期場次

保存的銷售頁程式會讀取網址中的 d，把字母 a～g 對應到星期一至星期日，再用來篩選報名視窗的場次。2026/11/3 逐頁打開六個有日期的銷售頁報名選單，顯示星期均符合各網址中的字母。這個參數選的是星期範圍，不是固定某一天；表中的查詢值如 today 會被拆成字母解析，實際對應週一與週四。

品牌 網址 d 值 報名視窗實際顯示
ADragon dg 11/5（四）、11/8（日）
SalesKing d 11/5（四）；另有候補選項
AI-NEXT ainext 11/6（五）、11/9（一）
AppIPO today 11/5（四）、11/9（一）；另有候補選項
AI Plus／n8n today 11/5（四）、11/9（一）；另有候補選項
AI First aifirst 11/7（六）、11/9（一）；另有候補選項
AI Creator 未帶 d 只有「報名候位」，沒有日期場次可供篩選

因此，六個有日期場次的銷售頁在本次檢查中確實顯示了符合 d 值的星期；AI Creator 是候位登記，不能視為已驗證 d 控制日期。程式另設有「篩選後沒有符合場次時回退原清單」的處理；若頁面設定為強制指定場次，也會直接顯示指定內容。因此 d 是場次呈現的篩選條件，不保證任何情況下都只顯示該星期。檢查只打開選單，沒有填寫或送出報名資料。

程式碼證據 P32 讀取 d、映射星期並套用場次篩選 
const signupSessionVariantKey = String(urlParams.get('d') || '').trim();

function xlabWeekdayVariantFromKey(key) {
    const weekdayMap = { a: '1', b: '2', c: '3', d: '4', e: '5', f: '6', g: '0' };
    const days = String(key || '').toLowerCase().split('').map(ch => weekdayMap[ch]).filter(Boolean);
    return days.length ? { '限定星期': days.join(',') } : null;
}

const urlSessionFilter = xlabBuildUrlSessionFilter();
generateAutoScheduleFromData(scheduleData, allowBackup, soldOutRaw,
    xlabMergeSessionFilters(null, urlSessionFilter));
S2有證據，結論有範圍

填寫聯絡資料前，未在保存表單中辨識出完整蒐集者名稱與權利管道

對七組保存表單的可見文字進行關鍵字檢查，並檢視姓名、email、手機等欄位附近的畫面；未辨識出可對應的公司／蒐集者完整名稱、完整個資蒐集告知及專門的權利行使方式。下方三張截圖是畫面示例，完整的七組關鍵字檢查結果列於 P03。課程文案提到「公司」或提供客服 LINE，並不等於已揭露誰在蒐集與如何處理資料。

個資法第 8 條列出蒐集者名稱、目的、資料類別、利用範圍、權利與行使方式等告知事項；本報告以此作為檢視項目，不就個別網站是否適用例外或構成違法作結論。

ADragon 個資表單

保存的表單畫面；未辨識出完整蒐集者名稱及權利行使說明。

AI-NEXT 個資表單

欄位以場次、姓名、email、電話與問題為主。

AI First 個資表單

同樣須填聯絡資料；以保存可見畫面為限。

設定證據 P03 七組可見表單文字的關鍵字檢查 
[
  {
    "頁面": "g1_form_AICREATOR",
    "可見表單文字長度": 447,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": []
  },
  {
    "頁面": "g2_form_adragon",
    "可見表單文字長度": 433,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": []
  },
  {
    "頁面": "g3_form_salesking",
    "可見表單文字長度": 441,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": []
  },
  {
    "頁面": "g4_form_ainext",
    "可見表單文字長度": 839,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": []
  },
  {
    "頁面": "g5_form_appipo",
    "可見表單文字長度": 1768,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": []
  },
  {
    "頁面": "g6_form_n8n",
    "可見表單文字長度": 745,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": []
  },
  {
    "頁面": "AI First",
    "可見表單文字長度": 563,
    "公司法定名稱關鍵字": [],
    "告知與權利行使關鍵字": [],
    "來源": "outputs/AI_First網站保存_20261102/pages/form/registration-form-observation.json"
  }
]
S3有證據，結論有範圍

人物與經歷：AICREATOR 標示講師與案例為示意；AI-NEXT 履歷未找到可交叉驗證來源

AI-NEXT 素材標示「Anna、29 歲、AI 自動化接案講師」並附個人故事。本次列出的搜尋未找到可交叉驗證該人物與經歷的獨立資料。

AICREATOR 則使用「Chloe Chou 周心怡」講師形象；有示意揭露講師為示意內容。

本次搜尋記錄："Anna" "AI-NEXT" 講師、"Anna" "29歲" "AI" "接案"、"Chloe Chou" "周心怡"；未找到可靠的相符人物履歷。搜尋結果可能漏掉非公開或未收錄的資料。

AI-NEXT 銷售頁首圖
AICREATOR：Chloe Chou 與模擬經歷
設定證據 P04 AICREATOR 的示意內容揭露 
{
  "報名頁文案": "每天想題目、寫腳本、做封面，是一人經營最累的地方。一個下午，用 AI 把一個月的短影音內容一次排好，而且聽起來還是你。目前開放候補登記，開課時間確定後會由專人聯繫說明場次與費用。頁面中的講師與案例為示意內容。"
}
S4有證據，結論有範圍

AICREATOR 表單只提供候位，方案與場次未確認

銷售頁顯示 NT$300，彈窗稱「限時0元報名試聽」，並以「立即報名」作為按鈕。長圖另列免費前 60 分鐘、300 元完整 4 小時及 1,800 元 VIP 方案，因此不能只憑價格不同就判定收費矛盾；但彈窗沒有清楚說明這次候補對應哪一個方案。

必填的「剩餘場次」選單只有「報名候位」，沒有可選日期或時間。彈窗說明也寫明目前是候補登記，等開課時間確定後再聯繫說明場次與費用。因此使用者送出的是候補資料，不是已選定場次的正式報名；「立即報名」與「報名成功」的字樣可能讓人誤以為已取得免費試聽或確定名額。

表單要求姓名、電子信箱與手機。送出成功後，程式會顯示「報名成功！」及可複製的報名編號，所以不能說畫面只有成功文字；但成功畫面沒有確認日期、時段、確切費用或參加方式。設定關閉 LINE 引導，成功畫面會隱藏 LINE／QR，也沒有交代專人何時、透過哪個管道聯繫。未能從前端確認是否另有後續 email 或簡訊。

頁首 NT$300

銷售頁價格與課程資訊。

AICREATOR 的候位彈窗

候補登記及「講師與案例為示意內容」的揭露存在；應保留這項反向證據。

三種參加方案

方案圖能解釋價格可能對應不同內容；彈窗仍未說明候補對應哪一項。

設定證據 P05 AICREATOR 價格、候補與 LINE 設定 
{
  "原價": 0,
  "優惠": "300",
  "場次query": "",
  "僅開場次": "報名候位",
  "Line ID": "",
  "報名頁文案": "每天想題目、寫腳本、做封面，是一人經營最累的地方。一個下午，用 AI 把一個月的短影音內容一次排好，而且聽起來還是你。目前開放候補登記，開課時間確定後會由專人聯繫說明場次與費用。頁面中的講師與案例為示意內容。",
  "Line 回覆訊息": "感謝登記「一人自媒體 AI 量產術」候補！開課時間確定後，會由專人與你聯繫說明場次與費用。",
  "LINE引導開關": false
}
原始碼證據 P06 LINE 引導關閉時的成功畫面 
2390                          : `我已報名\n${titleForMessage}\n${selectedSchedule}\n編號:${leadid}`;
2391                      document.getElementById('xlab-leadid-text').textContent = leadIdDisplay;
2392                      document.getElementById('xlab-display-leadid').style.display = 'block';
2393                      document.getElementById('xlab-display-leadid').setAttribute('data-copy', copyMessage);
2394                      const lineGuidanceEnabled = isLineGuidanceEnabled(pageData);
2395                      document.querySelectorAll('#xlabSuccessContent .xlab-line-required-card, #xlabSuccessContent .xlab-qr-card').forEach(el => el.style.display = lineGuidanceEnabled ? '' : 'none');
2396                      if (!lineGuidanceEnabled) {
2397                          document.getElementById('xlab-success-title').textContent = isConsultationJourney ? (pageData.__xlabRegistrationMode==='contact'?'諮詢資料已送出，專人將與你聯繫':'預約成功！') : '報名成功！';
2398                          document.getElementById('xlab-line-link').removeAttribute('href');
2399                          document.getElementById('xlab-qrcode-img').removeAttribute('src');
2400                          xlabSetModalMode('success');
2401                          xlabPulseEmbedHeight();
2402                          return;
2403                      }
2404                      const dynamicUrl = `https://line.me/R/oaMessage/${lineIdRaw}/?${encodeURIComponent(copyMessage)}`;
2405                      const lineButtonUrl = saved.lineUrl || dynamicUrl;
2406                      document.getElementById('xlab-line-link').href = lineButtonUrl;
S5程式／保存畫面可確認

「已報名人數」會隨日期自動增加

共用程式不是逐次查詢真實報名筆數，而是以設定基數，加上由課程代碼與日期雜湊算出的每日增量。AppIPO、n8n、AI First 的保存設定都有非零基數；其畫面人數因此包含人工設定與公式生成的成分。其他基數為 0 的頁面，不能一概說當時也展示了上萬人報名。

AppIPO 午夜後的人數

2026-11-02 跨日實測：14,511；與日期公式計算結果相同。

n8n 午夜後的人數

2026-11-02 跨日實測：14,904；與日期公式計算結果相同。

AI First 的報名頁

2026-11-02 當次畫面：已報名 15,404；基數 14,720、日增上限 10 可重算出此數字。

原始碼證據 P07 基數＋日期雜湊增量 
1442      function xlabStableDailyIncrement(seed, dayKey, max) {
1443          const limit = xlabNormalizeRegisteredNumber(max, 300);
1444          if (limit <= 0) return 0;
1445          const input = `${seed || 'signup'}:${dayKey}`;
1446          let hash = 2166136261;
1447          for (let i = 0; i < input.length; i += 1) {
1448              hash ^= input.charCodeAt(i);
1449              hash = Math.imul(hash, 16777619);
1450          }
1451          return (hash >>> 0) % (limit + 1);
1452      }
1453  
1454      function xlabCalculateRegisteredCount(data, todayKey = xlabTaipeiDateKey()) {
1455          const base = xlabNormalizeRegisteredNumber(data?.['已報名基數'], 0);
1456          if (base <= 0) return 0;
1457          const dailyMax = xlabNormalizeRegisteredNumber(data?.['已報名每日增加上限'], 300);
1458          const startKey = xlabNormalizeDateKey(data?.['已報名起算日']) || xlabNormalizeDateKey(data?.created_at) || todayKey;
1459          const startDay = xlabDayNumber(startKey);
1460          const todayDay = xlabDayNumber(todayKey);
1461          if (!Number.isFinite(startDay) || !Number.isFinite(todayDay) || todayDay <= startDay) return base;
1462          const seed = data?.query || data?.__xlabBaseQuery || data?.['報名卡片-標題'] || 'signup';
1463          let total = base;
1464          for (let day = startDay + 1; day <= todayDay; day += 1) {
1465              total += xlabStableDailyIncrement(seed, xlabDateKeyFromDayNumber(day), dailyMax);
1466          }
1467          return total;
1468      }
設定證據 P08 各品牌報名數設定與計算值 
[
  {
    "key": "AICREATOR",
    "name": "AICREATOR",
    "base": 0,
    "start": "2026-10-29",
    "dailyMax": 300,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 0,
    "nov2": 0
  },
  {
    "key": "adragon",
    "name": "ADragon",
    "base": 0,
    "start": null,
    "dailyMax": 0,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 0,
    "nov2": 0
  },
  {
    "key": "salesking",
    "name": "SalesKing",
    "base": 0,
    "start": "2026-10-16",
    "dailyMax": 300,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 0,
    "nov2": 0
  },
  {
    "key": "ainext",
    "name": "AI-NEXT",
    "base": 0,
    "start": null,
    "dailyMax": 300,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 0,
    "nov2": 0
  },
  {
    "key": "idea",
    "name": "AppIPO",
    "base": 12675,
    "start": "2026-07-03",
    "dailyMax": 30,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 14505,
    "nov2": 14511
  },
  {
    "key": "n8n",
    "name": "AI Plus／n8n",
    "base": 14720,
    "start": "2026-07-03",
    "dailyMax": 3,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 14901,
    "nov2": 14904
  },
  {
    "key": "aifirst",
    "name": "AI First",
    "base": 14720,
    "start": "2026-07-03",
    "dailyMax": 10,
    "discountDeadline": null,
    "nov1": 15395,
    "nov2": 15404
  }
]
S6使用者提供的觀察

ADragon 銷售頁主視覺是女性，10/25 直播畫面則是六指淵

ADragon 銷售頁主視覺使用女性照片；使用者提供的 10/25 直播截圖中，播放畫面可見男性講者，並由使用者確認為六指淵。兩個畫面呈現的人物不同，值得讀者留意。

現有銷售頁截圖不足以確認女性照片是否被明確標示為講師，因此本報告只記錄宣傳主視覺與實際直播畫面的落差，不推斷照片人物的身分或是否刻意冒充。

ADragon 銷售頁女性主視覺

頁面主視覺使用女性形象照。

10/25 ADragon 直播畫面

畫面中可見男性講者；講者為六指淵是使用者提供的辨識。

02

直播等待頁

文案如何稱呼活動，排程與連結又如何決定觀眾去哪裡。

W1程式／保存畫面可確認

d 參數會改變場次／星期篩選，但不是任意文字都有效

當沒有同名場次版本時，程式把 a～g 對應星期一至星期日：a=一、b=二、c=三、d=四、e=五、f=六、g=日；例如 d=dg 可選四、日。後台同名版本優先。today 不符合這個字母映射，需看有沒有同名版本；篩選後若沒有結果，程式還可能回退到原場次清單。

ADragon 等待頁

網址參數與頁面日期應一起記錄，避免不同版本互相比錯。

AI-NEXT 等待頁

相同模板呈現下一場日期與倒數。

原始碼證據 P09 d 的星期映射、同名版本優先與空篩選回退 
 506      function lglWeekdayVariantFromKey(key) {
 507        const cleanKey = String(key || "").trim().toLowerCase();
 508        if (!/^[a-g]+$/.test(cleanKey)) return null;
 509        const weekdayMap = { a: "1", b: "2", c: "3", d: "4", e: "5", f: "6", g: "0" };
 510        const seen = new Set();
 511        const days = [];
 512        cleanKey.split("").forEach(ch => {
 513          const day = weekdayMap[ch];
 514          if (!day || seen.has(day)) return;
 515          seen.add(day);
 516          days.push(day);
 517        });
 518        return days.length ? { "限定星期": days.join(",") } : null;
 519      }
 520  
 521      function lglPickSessionVariant(data, key) {
 522        const cleanKey = String(key || "").trim();
 523        if (!cleanKey) return null;
 524        const variants = lglParseSessionVariants(data?.["場次版本"]);
 525        const variant = variants[cleanKey];
 526        if (variant && typeof variant === "object" && !Array.isArray(variant)) return variant;
 527        return lglWeekdayVariantFromKey(cleanKey);
 528      }
 529  
 530      function lglApplySessionVariant(data, key) {
 531        const variant = lglPickSessionVariant(data, key);
 532        if (!variant) return data;
 533        const out = { ...data, "__lglSessionVariantKey": String(key || "").trim() };
 534        ["直播時間", "限定星期", "顯示場次", "僅開日期", "日期排除"].forEach(field => {
 535          if (!Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(variant, field)) return;
 536          const value = variant[field];
 537          if (value === undefined || value === null || value === "") return;
 538          out[field] = value;

··· 中間省略 ···

 753      function lglFilterSessionsByWeekdays(dataRow, sessions) {
 754        const selectedWeekdays = lglSelectedWeekdays(dataRow);
 755        if (!selectedWeekdays.size) return sessions;
 756        return sessions.filter(session => selectedWeekdays.has(String(session.start.getDay())));
 757      }
 758  
 759      function lglGetDisplaySessions(dataRow, maxSessionsDisplay) {
 760        const sessions = lglCalculateSessions(dataRow).slice(0, maxSessionsDisplay);
 761        const filteredSessions = lglFilterSessionsByWeekdays(dataRow, sessions);
 762        return filteredSessions.length ? filteredSessions : sessions;
 763      }
W2程式／保存畫面可確認

Console 能顯示站方自稱的「真人」與「預錄」連結分支

六個等待頁均接受 lglAdmin('huber') 開啟前端診斷。它只在本機 localStorage 記錄顯示開關，不是伺服器管理權限。程式優先使用「最新連結」，空白時改用星期別或預設預錄連結；診斷文字直接使用「最新連結（真人）」「預錄直播連結（預設）」等標示。

11/2 以 d=a 執行的六頁診斷中，「最新連結」均為空，採用來源均標示「預錄直播連結（預設）」。取得的 URL 是 /webinar/registration/… 註冊入口，不是影片檔，也不代表免註冊即可越過所有確認頁。

原始碼證據 P10 前端診斷開關與分支輸出 
 709      function lglIsAdmin() {
 710        try { return localStorage.getItem('__lgl_admin__') === '1'; } catch (e) { return false; }
 711      }
 712      window.lglAdmin = function (pass) {
 713        if (pass === false) {
 714          try { localStorage.removeItem('__lgl_admin__'); } catch (e) {}
 715          console.log('%c✗ Admin 已關閉', 'color:#ff3b30; font-weight:bold;');
 716          return;
 717        }
 718        if (pass === LGL_ADMIN_PASS) {
 719          try { localStorage.setItem('__lgl_admin__', '1'); } catch (e) {}
 720          console.log('%c✓ Admin 已啟用 — 重整頁面後會看到直播連結 debug', 'color:#30d158; font-weight:bold;');
 721        }

··· 中間省略 ···

 983        if (lglIsAdmin()) {
 984          const tw = lglTW(nextSession.start);
 985          const liveUrl = String(data["最新連結"] || "").trim();
 986          const dynamicRaw = String(data["動態直播連結"] || "").trim();
 987          const recorded = lglResolveRecordedLink(data, nextSession.start);
 988          const finalUrl = liveUrl || recorded.url;
 989          const source = liveUrl ? '最新連結（真人）' : (recorded.matched ? '每週預錄直播連結' : (recorded.url ? '預錄直播連結（預設）' : '❌ 無'));
 990          console.log('%c[Live URL Debug]', 'color:#0a84ff; font-weight:bold; font-size:13px;');
 991          console.log(`  場次日期:      ${tw.year}/${tw.month}/${tw.date} ${tw.time}`);
 992          console.log(`  最新連結:      ${liveUrl || '(空)'}`);
 993          console.log(`  動態連結原始:  ${dynamicRaw || '(空)'}`);
 994          console.log(`  預錄直播連結:  ${recorded.url || '(空)'}`);
 995          if (recorded.note) console.log(`  後台備註:      ${recorded.note}`);
 996          console.log(`%c  ✓ 會使用:      ${finalUrl || '(無)'}`, 'color:#30d158; font-weight:bold;');
 997          console.log(`  來源:          ${source}`);
 998        }
原始碼證據 P11 實際點擊時仍採相同分支 
1096          let liveUrl = String(data["最新連結"] || "").trim();
1097          let urlSource = "live";
1098          let recordedLink = null;
1099          if (!liveUrl) {
1100            const recorded = lglResolveRecordedLink(data, nextSession.start);
1101            recordedLink = recorded;
1102            liveUrl = recorded.url;
1103            urlSource = recorded.source;
1104          }
1105          if (!liveUrl) {
1106            alert("目前沒有可用的直播連結，請稍後再試或聯繫客服。");
1107            return;
1108          }
設定證據 P12 六個等待頁預錄分支的註冊入口 
[
  {
    "品牌": "ADragon",
    "頁面": "https://room.adragon.cc/?p=p&d=a",
    "註冊入口": "https://live.hipro.cc/webinar/registration/6ae2fcbeb5da13d31ca0cf5d",
    "當次診斷來源": "預錄直播連結（預設）",
    "最新連結": "空"
  },
  {
    "品牌": "SalesKing",
    "頁面": "https://room.hipro.cc/?p=salesking&d=a",
    "註冊入口": "https://live.hipro.cc/webinar/registration/6adc6d623d15a12d0688ea23",
    "當次診斷來源": "預錄直播連結（預設）",
    "最新連結": "空"
  },
  {
    "品牌": "AI-NEXT",
    "頁面": "https://room.ainext.pro/?p=ainext&d=a",
    "註冊入口": "https://live.hipro.cc/webinar/registration/6adc6af93d15a12d0688e773",
    "當次診斷來源": "預錄直播連結（預設）",
    "最新連結": "空"
  },
  {
    "品牌": "AppIPO",
    "頁面": "https://room.appipo.cc/?p=idea&d=a",
    "註冊入口": "https://live.hipro.cc/webinar/registration/6a572bfbf15c2390676e47da",
    "當次診斷來源": "預錄直播連結（預設）",
    "最新連結": "空"
  },
  {
    "品牌": "AI Plus／n8n",
    "頁面": "https://room.ai-plus.cc/?p=n8n&d=a",
    "註冊入口": "https://live.hipro.cc/webinar/registration/6a7307633770eb015a9afe79",
    "當次診斷來源": "預錄直播連結（預設）",
    "最新連結": "空"
  },
  {
    "品牌": "AI First",
    "頁面": "https://room.ai-first.vip/?p=aifirst&d=a",
    "註冊入口": "https://live.hipro.cc/webinar/registration/6abe3a08fcf048cd35970ce6",
    "當次診斷來源": "預錄直播連結（預設）",
    "最新連結": "空"
  }
]
W3有證據，結論有範圍

外層稱為「直播」，內部卻能分流到預錄

六個等待頁模板都含「進入直播」「直播即將開始，現在可以進入等候」等文字。進入排定時段後的「目前有一場正在直播喔」也是時鐘條件觸發，不是向攝影機或講師查詢是否在線。當次連結設定選中預錄分支，搭配下游影片與預排訊息，支持當次具錄播播放安排。

AI First 等待頁

課程與場次文案以「直播」稱呼。

n8n 等待頁

倒數與直播用語相鄰呈現。

原始碼證據 P13 按排定時間顯示「正在直播」 
1019  
1020        const entryOpenMinutes = lglGetEntryOpenMinutes(data);
1021        const entryCloseMinutes = lglGetEntryCloseMinutes(data);
1022        const entryCutoff = new Date(nextSession.start.getTime() + entryCloseMinutes * 60 * 1000);
1023        function lglTick() {
1024          const now = lglNow();
1025          const diff = nextSession.start - now;
1026          const isPreLive = diff <= entryOpenMinutes * 60 * 1000 && diff > 0;
1027          const isEntryOpen = now >= nextSession.start && now <= entryCutoff && now <= nextSession.end;
1028          const isCutoff = now > entryCutoff && now <= nextSession.end;
1029          document.getElementById("lgl_d").innerText = lglPad(Math.max(0, Math.floor(diff / 86400000)));
1030          document.getElementById("lgl_h").innerText = lglPad(Math.max(0, Math.floor(diff / 3600000) % 24));
1031          document.getElementById("lgl_m").innerText = lglPad(Math.max(0, Math.floor(diff / 60000) % 60));
1032          document.getElementById("lgl_s").innerText = lglPad(Math.max(0, Math.floor(diff / 1000) % 60));
1033          const hintEl = document.getElementById("lgl_openHint");
1034          const cutoffEl = document.getElementById("lgl_cutoffNotice");
1035          const formEl = document.getElementById("lgl_form");
1036          if (isTestMode || isPreLive || isEntryOpen) {
1037            formEl.style.display = "block";
1038            hintEl.style.display = "block";
1039            cutoffEl.style.display = "none";
1040            if (isEntryOpen) {
1041              hintEl.innerHTML = '<i class="fa-solid fa-circle-play"></i> 目前有一場正在直播喔，趕快進入！';
1042              hintEl.classList.add("lgl_open-hint--live");
1043            } else {
1044              hintEl.innerHTML = '<i class="fa-solid fa-video"></i> 直播即將開始，現在可以進入等候！';
1045              hintEl.classList.remove("lgl_open-hint--live");
1046            }
1047          } else if (isCutoff) {
1048            formEl.style.display = "none"; hintEl.style.display = "none"; cutoffEl.style.display = "block";
03

註冊頁與 thankyou

動態場次、電話檢查與轉址資料，發生在這一層。

R1程式／保存畫面可確認

「下一場直播」含以目前時間生成的 on-demand 場次

註冊頁與外層等待頁使用不同排程。保存的註冊程式啟用 JIT：先按 15 分鐘刻度取下一個時間，再每隔 30 分鐘建立一筆，共先產生 24 筆候選場次，標記 wk_on_demand_session = true。之後合併固定排程、排序、排除封鎖時段，通常選最早的一場。

AI-NEXT 註冊頁

第三層 WebinarKit 註冊入口，有自己的場次選單。

AI First 註冊頁

與外層 form／room 分屬不同頁面與程式。

原始碼證據 P14 15 分鐘刻度＋30 分鐘間隔＋on-demand 
  50    if (true) {
  51      let jit_date;
  52  
  53      if (`fifteen_minutes` === 'five_minutes') {
  54        jit_date = round_to_nearest_minute(new Date(), 5);
  55      } else if (`fifteen_minutes` === 'ten_minutes') {
  56        jit_date = round_to_nearest_minute(new Date(), 10);
  57      } else {
  58        jit_date = round_to_nearest_minute(new Date(), 15);
  59      }
  60  
  61      for (let i = 0; i < 24; i++) {
  62        let presentation_date = new Date(jit_date);
  63  
  64        presentation_date.wk_redirect_to = `watch_room`;
  65        presentation_date.wk_in_progress_label = ` - 進行中的直播`;
  66        presentation_date.wk_starts_in_label = ` - 剩 {{time}}`;
  67        presentation_date.wk_on_demand_session = true;
  68  
  69        presentation_dates.push(presentation_date);
  70  
  71        jit_date.setMinutes(jit_date.getMinutes() + 30);
  72      }
  73    }

··· 中間省略 ···

  78  
  79    for (let i = 0; i < webinar_dates.length; i++) {
  80      presentation_dates = presentation_dates.concat(get_presentation_date(webinar_dates[i], duration_ms));
  81    }
  82  
  83    presentation_dates.sort((a, b) => new Date(a).getTime() - new Date(b).getTime());
  84    presentation_dates = presentation_dates.filter(date => !blockout_dates.some(blocked_date => is_date_blocked(date, blocked_date)));

··· 中間省略 ···

 134        let number_of_sessions_to_show = registration_form.getAttribute('data-wk-number-of-sessions-to-show');
 135  
 136        if (!number_of_sessions_to_show || number_of_sessions_to_show === 'all' || element.options.length < parseInt(number_of_sessions_to_show)) {
 137          let clone = option.cloneNode(true);
 138  
 139          wk_reg_options.push(clone);
 140  
 141          element.add(clone);
 142        }
 143      });
 144    }
 145  
 146    let registration_timers = document.querySelectorAll('.wk_registration_timer');
 147  
 148    if (closest_date || show_instant_watch) { // session available
 149      webinar_registration_form_date_selects.forEach(function(element) {
 150        element.style.display = null;
原始碼證據 P15 取下一個時間刻度 
 354  function round_to_nearest_minute(date, minutes) {
 355    let ms = 1000 * 60 * minutes;
 356    return new Date(Math.ceil(date.getTime() / ms) * ms);
 357  }
 358  
 359  function get_presentation_date(webinarDate, duration) {
 360    let presentation_dates = [];
 361  
 362    let [hours, minutes] = webinarDate.time.split(':');
 363  
 364    if (hours === '12') {
 365      hours = '00';
 366    }
 367  
 368    if (webinarDate.period === 'PM') {
 369      hours = parseInt(hours, 10) + 12;
 370    }
設定證據 P16 前五組註冊頁排程分析 
[
  {
    "file": "adragon_wait_動態直播連結.html",
    "jit_enabled": true,
    "on_demand": true,
    "half_hour_step": true,
    "initial_sessions": 24,
    "rounds_15_minutes": true,
    "duration_minutes": "99.4"
  },
  {
    "file": "ainext_wait_動態直播連結.html",
    "jit_enabled": true,
    "on_demand": true,
    "half_hour_step": true,
    "initial_sessions": 24,
    "rounds_15_minutes": true,
    "duration_minutes": "61.65"
  },
  {
    "file": "idea_wait_動態直播連結.html",
    "jit_enabled": true,
    "on_demand": true,
    "half_hour_step": true,
    "initial_sessions": 24,
    "rounds_15_minutes": true,
    "duration_minutes": "72.86666666666666"
  },
  {
    "file": "n8n_wait_動態直播連結.html",
    "jit_enabled": true,
    "on_demand": true,
    "half_hour_step": true,
    "initial_sessions": 24,
    "rounds_15_minutes": true,
    "duration_minutes": "112.88333333333334"
  },
  {
    "file": "salesking_wait_動態直播連結.html",
    "jit_enabled": true,
    "on_demand": true,
    "half_hour_step": true,
    "initial_sessions": 24,
    "rounds_15_minutes": true,
    "duration_minutes": "73"
  }
]
R2有證據，結論有範圍

手機欄位會擋短數字與連號等無效測試號碼

使用者實測回報，輸入 12345678 或連續數字等測試號碼無法通過報名。保存的前端程式也顯示多層檢查：註冊頁用國碼解析與 iti.isValidNumber() 檢查格式；外層表單要求台灣手機為 09 開頭、共 10 碼，並呼叫 /api/invalid-phones/check 檢查無效號碼。12345678 不符合前端的開頭與位數規則；連號拒絕則是使用者實測結果，因具體判斷在 API 端，保存的前端程式看不到完整規則。兩套檢查分屬不同頁面流程。這些檢查仍不是簡訊 OTP：使用者曾回報自填的格式有效號碼成功到達 thankyou 頁，表示嚴格格式驗證不等於確認號碼由填表者持有。

原始碼證據 P17 註冊頁電話格式檢查 
 622    let custom_field_5 = registration_form.querySelector('.wk_registration_form_custom_field_5');
 623    let date_select = registration_form.querySelector('.wk_registration_form_date');
 624  
 625    let webinar_id = `6abe3a08fcf048cd35970ce6`;
 626  
 627    if (!webinar_id) {
 628      return;
 629    }
 630  
 631    if (!form_element.checkValidity()) {
 632      return form_element.reportValidity();
 633    }
 634  
 635    let iti = window.intlTelInputGlobals.getInstance(phone);
 636  
 637    if (phone.value && !iti.isValidNumber()) {
 638      phone.setCustomValidity('Please enter a valid phone number');
 639  
 640      return form_element.reportValidity();

··· 中間省略 ···

 660    let phone_number_country_code_value = '+' + iti.getSelectedCountryData().dialCode;
 661    let phone_number_value = iti.getNumber().replace(phone_number_country_code_value, '');
 662  
 663    let body = {
 664      firstName: first_name ? first_name.value : '',
 665      lastName: last_name ? last_name.value : '',
 666      email: email ? email.value : '',
 667      phoneNumberCountryCode: phone_number_country_code_value,
 668      phoneNumber: phone_number_value,
 669      customField1: custom_field_1 ? custom_field_1.value : '',
 670      customField2: custom_field_2 ? custom_field_2.value : '',
原始碼證據 P18 外層表單檢查 09 格式並呼叫無效手機 API 
2310    if (phoneVisible && !/^09\d{8}$/.test(phone)) {
2311        showInlineFieldError('xlabPhone', 'xlabPhoneError', '請填寫正確的臺灣手機號碼');
2312        firstInvalidInput = firstInvalidInput || phoneInput;
2313    }
2314    if (firstInvalidInput) {
2315        firstInvalidInput.focus({ preventScroll: true });
2316        return;
2317    }
… 中間程式略 …
2336    const invalidPhoneMessage = phoneVisible ? await getInvalidPhoneMessage(phone) : '';
2337    if (invalidPhoneMessage) {
2338        xlabSetPublicFormSubmitting(this, btn, false);
2339        showInlineFieldError('xlabPhone', 'xlabPhoneError', invalidPhoneMessage);
2340        phoneInput.focus({ preventScroll: true });
2341        return;
2342    }
… 中間程式略 …
2455    async function getInvalidPhoneMessage(phone) {
2456        try {
2457            const res = await fetch('/api/invalid-phones/check', {
2458                method: 'POST',
2459                headers: { 'Content-Type': 'application/json' },
2460                body: JSON.stringify({ phone })
2461            });
2462            if (res.status !== 422) return '';
2463            const data = await res.json().catch(() => ({}));
2464            return data && data.errors && data.errors.phone ? data.errors.phone : '此號碼無效，請重新輸入';
2465        } catch(e) {
2466            return '';
2467        }
2468    }
R3程式／保存畫面可確認

註冊電話會以 phone_number 參數出現在 thankyou 與直播網址

電話號碼會出現在網址的查詢參數中。使用者提供的 AI-NEXT thankyou 連結含有 phone_number 參數（號碼值經 URL 編碼；使用者表示是測試號碼）。前端也會把國碼與手機放入 JSON，POST 到註冊端點，再依 API 回傳的 data.url 跳轉。thankyou 轉址程式只刪除 r、t、e，其餘參數會帶入 watch 網址，因此 phone_number 仍會出現在直播頁網址中。

表單電話→註冊 POST→API 回傳 thankyou URL→保留 phone_number → watch

直播頁又從 URL 讀取電話，進頁送出 start，之後每 60 秒送出 hold 到「直播觀看頁人流狀況」資料表；payload 同時包含 phone 和完整 URL。這是觀看追蹤。

原始碼證據 P19 電話在註冊 POST 本文，API 回傳含 phone_number 的 thankyou URL 
 700    let phone_number_country_code_value = '+' + iti.getSelectedCountryData().dialCode;
 701    let phone_number_value = iti.getNumber().replace(phone_number_country_code_value, '');
 702  
 703    let body = {
 704      firstName: first_name ? first_name.value : '',
 705      lastName: last_name ? last_name.value : '',
 706      email: email ? email.value : '',
 707      phoneNumberCountryCode: phone_number_country_code_value,
 708      phoneNumber: phone_number_value,
 709      customField1: custom_field_1 ? custom_field_1.value : '',
 710      customField2: custom_field_2 ? custom_field_2.value : '',
 711      customField3: custom_field_3 ? custom_field_3.value : '',
 712      customField4: custom_field_4 ? custom_field_4.value : '',
 713      customField5: custom_field_5 ? custom_field_5.value : '',
 714      date: date,
 715      fullDate: date_text,
 716      timeZone: Intl.DateTimeFormat().resolvedOptions().timeZone,
 717      redirect_to: redirect_to,
 718      on_demand_session: on_demand_session,
 719      referrer: document.referrer
 720    };
 721  

··· 中間省略 ···

 740  function webinarkit_post_registration(id, body) {
 741    let post_url = '/webinar/external/registration/' + id;
 742  
 743    let url_search_params = new URLSearchParams(window.location.search);
 744  
 745    let query = url_search_params.toString();
 746  
 747    if (query) {
 748      post_url = post_url + '?' + query;
 749    }
 750  
 751    fetch(post_url, {
 752      method: 'POST',
 753      headers: {
 754        'Accept': 'application/json',
 755        'Content-Type': 'application/json'
 756      },
 757      body: JSON.stringify(body)
 758    })
 759    .then(response => {
 760      return response.json();
 761    })
 762    .then(data => {
 763      if (data) {
 764        window.top.location.href = data.url;
 765      }
 766    })
 767    .catch(err => {
 768      console.log(err);
原始碼證據 P20 thankyou 只刪 r／t／e，其他參數轉入 watch 
 898        let url_search_params = new URLSearchParams(window.location.search);
 899        url_search_params.delete('r');
 900        url_search_params.delete('t');
 901        url_search_params.delete('e');
 902  
 903        let query = url_search_params.toString();
 904  
 905        if (query) {
 906          query = '&' + query;
 907        }
 908  
 909        if (``) {
 910          window.top.location.href = `` + `?t=` + wk_time + '&r=' + wk_registrant_id + query;
 911        } else {
 912          window.top.location.href = `/webinar/watch/` + `6adc6af93d15a12d0688e773` + `?t=` + wk_time + '&r=' + wk_registrant_id + query;
 913        }
原始碼證據 P21 從 URL 讀電話並定期送出 hold 
3870    function startViewerTracking() {
3871      var query = new URLSearchParams(window.location.search);
3872      var viewer = {
3873        name: cleanValue(query.get("first_name") || query.get("name")),
3874        phone: cleanValue(query.get("phone_number") || query.get("phone")),
3875        email: cleanValue(query.get("email"))
3876      };
3877  
3878      if (!viewer.name && !viewer.phone && !viewer.email) {
3879        console.warn(
3880          "[viewer-tracking] No viewer identity was found in the URL query."
3881        );
3882        return;
3883      }
3884  
3885      var endpoint =
3886        CONFIG.supabaseUrl.replace(/\/$/, "") +
3887        "/rest/v1/" +
3888        encodeURIComponent(CONFIG.trackingTable);
3889  

··· 中間省略 ···

3902          body: JSON.stringify({
3903            name: viewer.name,
3904            phone: viewer.phone,
3905            email: viewer.email,
3906            type: type,
3907            url: window.location.href
3908          })
3909        }).then(function (response) {

··· 中間省略 ···

3926      writeEvent("start");
3927      trackingTimer = window.setInterval(function () {
3928        if (isPlaybackOwner) {
3929          writeEvent("hold");
3930        }
3931      }, CONFIG.holdIntervalMs);
3932    }
04

直播頁

從播放、畫面人數、預排聊天，到真實訊息的可見範圍。

L1有證據，結論有範圍

播放器將影片位置同步到場次時間

AI-NEXT 播放器載入固定 HLS 來源，並以「現在時間－場次時間」計算應播放的秒數，誤差超過一秒便把播放位置跳到該秒數。配合 on-demand 分支與預排內容，顯示它具備將既有影片包裝成定時場次播放的機制。使用者另外回報比較兩場後，講師話語與影片相同。

AI-NEXT 播放室

影片與聊天欄並列，是觀眾看到的直播介面。

AI First 播放室

預錄與預排互動可在同一播放頁中同步。

原始碼證據 P22 固定影片來源與場次時間同步 
   1  function play_webinar() {
   2    player = videojs('video');
   3  
   4    player.src({
   5      src: 'https://vz-3f780a95-e11.b-cdn.net/014239eb-6299-43be-bf7a-e50289000742/playlist.m3u8',
   6      type: 'application/x-mpegURL'
   7    });

··· 中間省略 ···

  70  function sync_player_time() {
  71    time_since_event_start = (Date.now() - event_start_date.getTime()) / 1000;
  72  
  73    if (time_since_event_start > 0) {
  74      let sync_difference = Math.abs(player.currentTime() - time_since_event_start);
  75  
  76      console.log('sync_difference: ' + sync_difference);
  77  
  78      if (sync_difference > 1) {
  79        console.log('Time not synced, changing player currentTime')
  80  
  81        player.currentTime(time_since_event_start);
  82      }
  83    }
  84  }
L2程式／保存畫面可確認

畫面在線人數由 JS 在指定範圍生成

保存的直播頁設定把人數下限、上限定為 235 與 255，並依時間、區間與亂數更新。開場另有從約 30 人爬升的流程。這條顯示路徑不以伺服器實際連線人數為輸入。

原始碼證據 P23 人數上下限及更新邏輯 
   5    var CONFIG = {
   6      // ===== 在線人數規則 =====
   7      postStartRampMinutes: 5,
   8      startingCount: 30,
   9      liveMinCount: 235,
  10      liveMaxCount: 255,
  11      rampIntervalMinMs: 1200,
  12      rampIntervalMaxMs: 3200,
  13      changeIntervalMinMs: 3000,
  14      changeIntervalMaxMs: 20000,

··· 中間省略 ···

3819          } else if (difference > 0) {
3820            displayedCount += Math.min(difference, randomInt(1, 4));
3821          } else if (difference < 0) {
3822            displayedCount -= Math.min(Math.abs(difference), randomInt(1, 2));
3823          }
3824  
3825          displayedCount = clamp(
3826            displayedCount,
3827            CONFIG.startingCount - 2,
3828            CONFIG.liveMinCount
3829          );
3830        }
3831        nextDelay = randomInt(
3832          CONFIG.rampIntervalMinMs,
3833          CONFIG.rampIntervalMaxMs
3834        );
3835      } else {
3836        if (displayedCount === null) {
3837          displayedCount = randomInt(
3838            CONFIG.liveMinCount,
3839            CONFIG.liveMaxCount
3840          );
3841        } else {
3842          var direction = chooseOscillationDirection(
3843            CONFIG.liveMinCount,
3844            CONFIG.liveMaxCount
3845          );
3846          displayedCount = clamp(
3847            displayedCount + direction,
3848            CONFIG.liveMinCount,
3849            CONFIG.liveMaxCount
3850          );
3851        }
3852        nextDelay = randomInt(
3853          CONFIG.changeIntervalMinMs,
3854          CONFIG.changeIntervalMaxMs
3855        );
3856      }
3857  
3858      renderAudienceCount();
L3程式／保存畫面可確認

大量聊天室內容已寫在原始碼，按影片秒數出現

預排 chatMessages 內含暱稱、文字與指定分鐘／秒數，角色同時包含「助教」及以 Guest 編號呈現的訪客。JS 用 setTimeout 到點直接呼叫顯示函式，因此不需等某位觀眾當時發訊。內容涵蓋學習反應、詢價、預約、購買與名額提醒。若觀看者把聊天室理解為即時互動，可能會把預排訊息看成當下留言；這是依顯示方式做出的判讀。下方完整列出六個保存直播室的陣列；空陣列也一併保留。

播放室保存樣本 預排則數 輸入列
ADragon 0 隱藏
SalesKing 0 隱藏
AI-NEXT 83 可見
AppIPO 1 隱藏
AI Plus／n8n 225 可見
AI First 59 可見
AI-NEXT 聊天紀錄

累積 25 則訊息後截取最新位置；當次已知頁面預載 83 則時間軸訊息。

n8n 聊天紀錄

累積 27 則訊息後截取最新位置；當次已知頁面預載 225 則時間軸訊息。

AI First 聊天紀錄

累積 12 則訊息後截取；當次頁面預載 59 則時間軸訊息。右上在線數亦由共用程式生成。

原始碼證據 P24 按預排時間直接加入聊天畫面 
 144    for (let i = 0; i < chatMessages.length; i++) {
 145      let chat_message_display_minute = chatMessages[i].display_minute;
 146  
 147      let chat_message_display_second = chatMessages[i].display_second;
 148  
 149      if ((chat_message_display_minute * 60) + (chat_message_display_second * 1) > time_since_event_start) { // Prevent flood of chat messages on page load
 150        setTimeout(function(chatMessage) {
 151          let item = {
 152            message: chatMessage.text,
 153            id: '',
 154            username: chatMessage.username,
 155            type: 'message'
 156          };
 157  
 158          addMessageUtility(item);
 159        }, ((chat_message_display_minute * 60 * 1000) + (chat_message_display_second * 1000)) - (time_since_event_start * 1000), chatMessages[i]);
 160      }
 161    }
完整陣列 1 ADragon 完整 chatMessages 陣列（0 則） 
[]
完整陣列 2 SalesKing 完整 chatMessages 陣列（0 則） 
[]
完整陣列 3 AI-NEXT 完整 chatMessages 陣列（83 則） 
[
  {
    "username": "Guest 916",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "0ede5a2d-f33a-46dd-8ba9-584c13576c3e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 66",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "9a2e0fe3-6a5c-4c12-8d98-de62e6f23742"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 861",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "17b51998-0061-4f8c-acee-30362c5caf9d"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "歡迎大家在聊天室互動～～",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "8037a8a3-2072-4a9b-841b-04ddeece00c1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 654",
    "text": "+211111",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 23,
    "id": "b24848cd-7c65-4ad6-a280-c3f44035202a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 861",
    "text": "+11！！！",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 30,
    "id": "b0a6f668-3df5-43dc-8290-0de2b39e612d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 793",
    "text": "Hi Anna ~~~",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 56,
    "id": "dcdd2605-119a-4d20-9708-147441016e12"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 37",
    "text": "老師好",
    "display_minute": 1,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "7b6bfbab-800f-465f-92d4-8b3f99a3f191"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 361",
    "text": "XD",
    "display_minute": 1,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "765298c1-16b1-4a46-8d2e-2b56488f9eb8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 861",
    "text": "行政職",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "4ebb2f75-277f-4838-a6ff-ab61a64b1a72"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 317",
    "text": "業務",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "b72dd005-ee54-491e-9456-3aff08d58bae"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 949",
    "text": "設計ㄕ",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 15,
    "id": "e2465abd-7ff9-4a52-8fc4-e5b0efa40b35"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 660",
    "text": "工程師",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "b4ae9864-6626-4b71-8175-11b9451a9290"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 769",
    "text": "保險",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "c46d1948-982c-4fd2-89ad-1d7d2781821e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 798",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "e197605d-48f9-4e6a-b78b-974e547de464"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 234",
    "text": "B",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "2876bf42-0f74-439e-a294-a4bdee8a48ed"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 852",
    "text": "CCCCC",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 5,
    "id": "bb8e036c-1fb8-4d9a-9dd0-71c6cd18be42"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 145",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "273c6143-e7d0-4395-bc07-42a5e270bf94"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 89",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 14,
    "id": "256899a1-4a0a-4b09-8ab5-1dd567bf6d45"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 764",
    "text": "B",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 19,
    "id": "1e5e7563-800b-4254-8dad-e2bd961abece"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 822",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 32,
    "id": "2deffc7b-83d1-473d-915a-483550aa2b77"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 256",
    "text": "B",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "93fe37fc-7e78-4a8a-94ed-270e34d9567c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 167",
    "text": "d",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 55,
    "id": "e399a6ef-6fcd-4b59-ac5c-6123504f6a59"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 672",
    "text": "想學短影～～",
    "display_minute": 4,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "00c22fd3-5576-4aa9-a7f0-e5ec92a113c2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 898",
    "text": "👍",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 34,
    "id": "9cc1b173-1ef7-418e-a312-34ab6b56043b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 636",
    "text": "數位遊牧😮",
    "display_minute": 7,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "cbe3c1f6-9f36-47ac-a01c-b847e5c91d15"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 310",
    "text": "還沒開始做副業",
    "display_minute": 8,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "1dee90ec-95b2-4c61-9f18-0aade8b5f370"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 249",
    "text": "2ㄍ",
    "display_minute": 8,
    "display_second": 30,
    "id": "c78d9e4b-fa99-4d3d-86fe-27930de52bd4"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 839",
    "text": "藍海都沒有",
    "display_minute": 9,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "d2ed0a70-400d-4648-aa94-7d66be6548a7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 833",
    "text": "AI",
    "display_minute": 9,
    "display_second": 38,
    "id": "9c3ba1f3-0a3d-483e-8380-b5e9175b4ddb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 118",
    "text": "所以是說開發門檻降低了 人人都可以",
    "display_minute": 12,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "b8b189f8-a85c-494d-a7b1-746c866b2bc2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 688",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "411aea6b-bc7f-4e62-9ddf-ad91c10397b5"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 475",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "a045a4ea-b37c-4b9e-9ccb-8c232d8c7430"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 94",
    "text": "+111",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 9,
    "id": "6ab95232-0dc6-42a1-b7e8-129fdf475771"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 20",
    "text": "+1~~~~~~~~~~~~",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 19,
    "id": "4ebb6352-99e0-4295-8905-8af95a4ac031"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 399",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 29,
    "id": "24d33247-61af-409f-8861-fb995836768c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 692",
    "text": "我是2",
    "display_minute": 16,
    "display_second": 45,
    "id": "18337c73-aed1-4fe5-9f91-a2d259f602cb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 347",
    "text": "找案源比較難",
    "display_minute": 17,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "161dd50a-4d46-4d94-9980-b5dd6e97aa66"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 738",
    "text": "👍",
    "display_minute": 17,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "bb4184f4-d298-43c5-b4ec-8ff2bcfbe0d7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 233",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 17,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "0b206393-171a-4db5-a300-3e7893135978"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 355",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 17,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "866d43bf-1c93-4133-bd26-c968b583d01b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 286",
    "text": "不錯ㄛ～～好建議",
    "display_minute": 22,
    "display_second": 54,
    "id": "af8558e5-f670-4b19-9e33-7970b0ee7c47"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 277",
    "text": "血淚...><",
    "display_minute": 24,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "b2662d0e-74e0-4567-9f8b-eef0f19e8e9a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 685",
    "text": "之前被改到飽",
    "display_minute": 24,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "301f7d78-e4dc-47e0-afe1-90641d3947cf"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 109",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 3,
    "id": "a7fc9a80-2cca-41e6-a793-86a4409747fd"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 931",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "d942a8be-da46-4f27-b03a-a936e6da655f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 331",
    "text": "看起來還真實用噎",
    "display_minute": 33,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "b49e6c61-5ac8-4866-9f91-ad65b1dcdec9"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 712",
    "text": "cool",
    "display_minute": 34,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "31defdc4-5b6e-44cf-9d46-f7381cb7285b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 698",
    "text": "哇年齡層很廣~",
    "display_minute": 35,
    "display_second": 48,
    "id": "af3fd7c4-5537-44b4-a76f-f43e6002ff66"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 632",
    "text": "以我目前的實力來說很難..",
    "display_minute": 37,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "8a654353-7168-4a19-bc69-aa47dcba508e"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "不會的！我們這邊有各行各業的學員～都有完成品唷！",
    "display_minute": 37,
    "display_second": 45,
    "id": "9dd85b0e-0dc0-4e1b-b9b6-f6959001377c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 23",
    "text": "😮",
    "display_minute": 38,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "51329ce8-0173-4b2f-882c-ac1fd858b6a1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 760",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "ecd93833-fbe1-400b-ab35-9b68e4ea3b47"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 379",
    "text": "C",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "2124a630-1426-4069-a9ff-32fee525fffb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 585",
    "text": "A@@",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "621df304-a275-4cf9-9e6b-a0f273d5d2e1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 802",
    "text": "BBB",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "4ccc6ce4-e116-4a19-9dd3-29a6abc63f16"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 158",
    "text": "C",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "47b3223c-031e-43cc-8e7d-e2dfaac36a47"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 497",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 37,
    "id": "0e0fc866-109b-4a3b-b766-48f15ef68107"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 663",
    "text": "A",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "acf799ef-a419-4c2e-8ce2-b91fcf8966ea"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 133",
    "text": "c",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 52,
    "id": "b538fdb1-3606-4d16-a8fb-5d08c6884cbf"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 433",
    "text": "眼花撩亂",
    "display_minute": 41,
    "display_second": 15,
    "id": "c1c036e7-a3a5-4108-89cb-5246a9c1190b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 639",
    "text": "厲害唷！",
    "display_minute": 42,
    "display_second": 24,
    "id": "eb64bd54-0dec-4263-a35a-e5d3f7c94210"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 502",
    "text": "2",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "483aafe1-3b9f-4715-9c18-cd0f49d8616e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 691",
    "text": "2",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 39,
    "id": "dc99bc4e-5d68-4c0c-8871-e5d3fe853dd5"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 245",
    "text": "3",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "dee66b32-71c3-4cee-9341-9491a82360cc"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 579",
    "text": "1",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "d8987c23-20df-45dd-9094-bf464b5c5083"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 8",
    "text": "1",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 42,
    "id": "8aaa2d21-4718-4731-b953-5e871716703b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 547",
    "text": "＋1",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "40fd9369-5ba4-441d-8a12-2cddd4e23cad"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 458",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 37,
    "id": "f3a16e2d-3ec9-426c-9706-f01d255335a8"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "官方LINE唷～",
    "display_minute": 49,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "08cba930-e293-499e-8951-ce6f517e7b88"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 58",
    "text": "想知道加招式的~",
    "display_minute": 51,
    "display_second": 32,
    "id": "4f2a964b-26cb-49b3-9faf-adda79930cbb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 508",
    "text": "已私訊",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "3c0179b4-063d-43b3-8742-ffa54880badf"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 368",
    "text": "拿到ㄌ",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 44,
    "id": "a378084c-a951-40c6-89d3-9d88b0a62890"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 324",
    "text": "拿",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 50,
    "id": "f1aa2ff5-0578-4c79-9985-c7a9fa967653"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 38",
    "text": "666",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 55,
    "id": "d0cb07b1-ace3-4711-a589-1b91c53dc28a"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "是在LINE唷！",
    "display_minute": 53,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "85689992-3db2-45e5-bfb3-cc3a06fa0b05"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "第一位同學下單囉！陳O瑜",
    "display_minute": 53,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "ace1993d-d2d0-4c8e-a959-06e4654228c2"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "感謝 張O芯",
    "display_minute": 53,
    "display_second": 46,
    "id": "19b59238-1f63-45dd-9d26-33c78ebebe95"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "感謝 林O",
    "display_minute": 54,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "ac211209-94c5-428f-ac68-4aed3bc64a10"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "同學陸續下單中！！",
    "display_minute": 54,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "e33a0274-f109-444c-9ba9-392af1616983"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "謝謝老師～",
    "display_minute": 56,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "cb4d5f42-e5d0-48d5-9947-7c715a6cad91"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 528",
    "text": "有收穫",
    "display_minute": 56,
    "display_second": 13,
    "id": "1a553110-098f-410c-8cbd-3723d07c8363"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 953",
    "text": "有收穫！謝謝老師",
    "display_minute": 56,
    "display_second": 21,
    "id": "8a845c03-ba1d-4ebe-a0a0-154ef1492794"
  }
]
完整陣列 4 AppIPO 完整 chatMessages 陣列（1 則） 
[
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "嗨 大家記得在Line上面打上簽到，待會留言我們都在Line上面留會有AI做遊戲互動歐！",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "1783934253172"
  }
]
完整陣列 5 AI Plus／n8n 完整 chatMessages 陣列（225 則） 
[
  {
    "username": "Guest 687",
    "text": "嗨嗨",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "a5aab8ff-7e13-4818-8f84-1249c9b351da"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 4",
    "text": "嗨",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "e7b97a93-5d0c-4914-b52f-17e62733cfce"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 974",
    "text": "老師好！",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "74e7fd49-7b39-4182-8fd9-199f871bdad1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 135",
    "text": "好欸",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 17,
    "id": "2911eaf7-6ac4-40a8-827e-a1fcad801cf0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 34",
    "text": "房仲",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 34,
    "id": "bf7f3c2b-f9f1-489f-90d1-aa5ba1187375"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 425",
    "text": "直銷",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 38,
    "id": "9eb2496f-026d-4f46-8fbd-ea8ef793b3cf"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 208",
    "text": "餐飲業",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 42,
    "id": "f9d26c72-8ccf-407e-a494-69a459bebb15"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 653",
    "text": "美業！",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 49,
    "id": "f18480d7-e45d-445e-bc27-e714e24e63b7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 65",
    "text": "寵物業可以嗎",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "ac2ccc83-dccb-4f87-82bb-ac2c556e3d56"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 944",
    "text": "老闆",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 56,
    "id": "84f42f89-9432-4df3-83a0-b36d0ff1cb92"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 181",
    "text": "員工",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "1107181a-88ac-469c-abf5-975adf54e210"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 394",
    "text": "社畜",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "749ebd62-60d0-408f-a59c-a27d15aa3505"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 109",
    "text": "熊貓～",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 2,
    "id": "8a2f97de-503c-4fb4-83e9-dbd9a8ae6b35"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 113",
    "text": "兼職人員",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 5,
    "id": "f317fc41-d9af-4314-b427-b9978d81c512"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 910",
    "text": "可憐的保險業",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 9,
    "id": "c329749d-cfca-496f-824a-fbec7a052a23"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 97",
    "text": "生心靈",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "159830dc-fa42-4dda-99ba-c30ec32d3940"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 324",
    "text": "行政",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "d3b67c51-94ee-4926-ae0b-9368beb80363"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 695",
    "text": "在中山開酒吧",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 15,
    "id": "1a0036e2-1388-439d-b348-cf411b82e1a6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 80",
    "text": "護理師",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "28111bbe-b5f3-4bfa-b420-6a6ea3449c2e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 735",
    "text": "健身",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 17,
    "id": "2c401cca-ad23-42f9-87cd-1fe8fc5b62a5"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 250",
    "text": "賣水果的",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "989b2c50-8ff1-46fe-94b3-754fc8d9a334"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 765",
    "text": "老師從小看你影片長大",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "43d9fa71-5262-465c-a4fa-be4715156990"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 207",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "066eba3b-becb-44b1-98b4-683ee57e48c2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 637",
    "text": "直銷～",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "13989a19-5ac0-43ed-950c-fabb27a42fea"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 643",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 28,
    "id": "6b6897b9-2513-442d-a082-bcc5b9cd77e1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 751",
    "text": "<3",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 32,
    "id": "92414764-c575-4ea6-8d26-076e4f08ffaf"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 65",
    "text": "GOGO!",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "81f2e025-1636-4478-9a66-31a35316c01e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 741",
    "text": "直接開始！",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 47,
    "id": "542944fb-405c-4af1-84bb-33e5080e5387"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 806",
    "text": "好",
    "display_minute": 6,
    "display_second": 49,
    "id": "22ce6d60-8eb0-4040-ab8d-035a2056a947"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 306",
    "text": "＄＄＄＄＄",
    "display_minute": 7,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "e8f6b030-d9ce-4e47-8103-21b0a580c809"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 448",
    "text": "＄＄",
    "display_minute": 8,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "3de6e8c5-8e32-417b-9c34-c10df9ecb4e3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 814",
    "text": "想聽！",
    "display_minute": 8,
    "display_second": 37,
    "id": "b6b64be8-8299-4de1-9891-924af21112a6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 256",
    "text": "很需要欸",
    "display_minute": 8,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "84bb2c7c-39d1-4784-9206-b8ae597aa92d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 785",
    "text": "老師好！",
    "display_minute": 9,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "cd146e9e-c32f-4a2e-965e-3a7b90373f49"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 325",
    "text": "🔥",
    "display_minute": 10,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "0425b63a-fc6a-43e8-94c5-8d1d3fedf9ed"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 667",
    "text": "幾年有上過第一屆高效剪輯課 66很用心教",
    "display_minute": 10,
    "display_second": 19,
    "id": "626272b0-4aa2-4369-89b5-2dce172bcd4d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 240",
    "text": "求老闆",
    "display_minute": 10,
    "display_second": 34,
    "id": "95eae66f-2f46-498f-b82c-23c03225d9cd"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 946",
    "text": "ＸＤ",
    "display_minute": 10,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "19e53410-7cd4-4daf-aead-1b6945167ff3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 37",
    "text": "加班",
    "display_minute": 10,
    "display_second": 56,
    "id": "e2a90ca8-3b87-49d8-b959-8068f2f70596"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 748",
    "text": "無名正妹",
    "display_minute": 12,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "e881c4e4-96b0-4ff6-b372-2bccf9c870c4"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 923",
    "text": "暴露年紀",
    "display_minute": 13,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "e37a9071-e9b5-4c24-afae-19ce955ee806"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 866",
    "text": "太難了",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 52,
    "id": "8160f1de-1c56-48f7-a475-623f3f7d14d3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 505",
    "text": "😢",
    "display_minute": 15,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "179cc202-1f93-4d5f-942b-cf0f484541e0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 873",
    "text": "😭",
    "display_minute": 15,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "a4c9c818-75e9-4ebb-951f-dbd4f56c4213"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 519",
    "text": "😢",
    "display_minute": 15,
    "display_second": 30,
    "id": "f24107f7-77c1-4024-8e7c-a3f4b54a5233"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 91",
    "text": "＋1",
    "display_minute": 18,
    "display_second": 55,
    "id": "4978798d-ef4c-441b-9633-92f7286e964b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 207",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 19,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "a14095ae-a88f-40f6-805b-558666e8c28a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 643",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 19,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "ecd2a8b6-c0c0-485b-ae8b-1e6eee5fcf86"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 15",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 19,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "7874a816-e5ec-43ed-acbf-1bd8e4f07c4b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 179",
    "text": "懶+1",
    "display_minute": 19,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "bc45df1f-147c-4c5e-a3be-d4d586befe29"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 127",
    "text": "懶",
    "display_minute": 19,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "4a9ffadb-efd1-4672-b50a-ea68d865b603"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 905",
    "text": "＋1",
    "display_minute": 19,
    "display_second": 51,
    "id": "fb5eb823-66f6-4667-a5a4-4bddcf626413"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 407",
    "text": "有聽過",
    "display_minute": 20,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "aecb578e-fbd0-45d5-8d2d-7be880f3d2d6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 282",
    "text": "我要我要",
    "display_minute": 22,
    "display_second": 51,
    "id": "6d0bd68d-9060-4bb2-9489-c82b4c39e7b8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 141",
    "text": "五星XDD",
    "display_minute": 25,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "4d091c64-cbe1-4665-8651-280251e960fb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 69",
    "text": "🤩",
    "display_minute": 26,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "9df87250-3d35-4935-aa1a-dc3c6475b5f3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 270",
    "text": "想學～",
    "display_minute": 26,
    "display_second": 45,
    "id": "63f64c66-cdd1-4bde-9520-ffc6936e1ec2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 477",
    "text": "神",
    "display_minute": 27,
    "display_second": 56,
    "id": "0f4ce1c2-e2ce-4bca-a7c2-587572415a53"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 495",
    "text": "我需要這個QQ",
    "display_minute": 28,
    "display_second": 42,
    "id": "8d7c87fd-c3c9-4c57-9def-1a4eebc9c80b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 110",
    "text": "左下",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "c5d464a1-fa2b-4881-ab69-60a1d4e1b751"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 494",
    "text": "WOW",
    "display_minute": 31,
    "display_second": 54,
    "id": "0fd64ad6-2975-46e9-9408-d7e4fb6231d8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 237",
    "text": "！！！",
    "display_minute": 32,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "d6b713fd-8c97-4e6e-9dde-0ac25d0a9299"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 38",
    "text": "需要～",
    "display_minute": 32,
    "display_second": 54,
    "id": "cccc4552-f031-497b-80bc-df32ceb8d8c2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 984",
    "text": "素材自動找！？",
    "display_minute": 33,
    "display_second": 21,
    "id": "fd56f9db-b6ba-466f-91cb-58801884803c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 433",
    "text": "帥",
    "display_minute": 34,
    "display_second": 51,
    "id": "e83ddeff-78a4-4d11-9409-5572018a9e07"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 844",
    "text": "😮",
    "display_minute": 35,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "bbc06e8e-2649-4d3a-9e37-d5dcc40093f1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 877",
    "text": "想當薪水小偷",
    "display_minute": 37,
    "display_second": 2,
    "id": "fcdcc583-d5d7-48d2-90dd-f76ce3cd650e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 531",
    "text": "＋1",
    "display_minute": 38,
    "display_second": 13,
    "id": "271adaee-dcbf-404a-8abc-1359dc4024e2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 535",
    "text": "幫助我",
    "display_minute": 39,
    "display_second": 30,
    "id": "86ffa63e-f886-4706-841e-a8e4a6327567"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 496",
    "text": "我們家就是做易經的",
    "display_minute": 40,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "1509e268-9d72-4e34-9132-97331e694ddb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 171",
    "text": "ＸＤ",
    "display_minute": 41,
    "display_second": 13,
    "id": "79be151d-c404-4d4a-8caa-5fae889ff27c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 725",
    "text": "屌",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 19,
    "id": "53146cc6-ad6c-4c6d-a437-603a10e49f93"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 639",
    "text": "做不出來",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "a67f6e75-a28b-4183-92f4-e988a4e0aaa3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 951",
    "text": "請問也可以不學 直接讓老師的團隊幫我們直接服務操作嗎？\n我們有大概20W預算",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "617990e8-8816-4ab2-85be-a982cac0e9d7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 769",
    "text": "做不出來",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "cd0e31a3-5f1e-494e-a676-08b558e6f732"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 396",
    "text": "500",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "9f90f3f8-2ff3-429a-bf77-8652b88f93c8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 525",
    "text": "做不出來",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "f340f96d-e9ff-4d50-89aa-54dfd311df20"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 4",
    "text": "1200",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "c1d8706d-8c66-454b-a3c4-a70ad97803aa"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 880",
    "text": "難",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "209c2bab-5ad6-4c48-9df3-7e16a4f1fe92"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 954",
    "text": "600",
    "display_minute": 44,
    "display_second": 54,
    "id": "3f87cadb-44af-4a9e-be99-61b59aee4a24"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 63",
    "text": "250",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "8d52d71a-945d-4afb-ad07-39971309cdd3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 795",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "4f5dd8e9-4264-48cc-b301-960b1df2e8d1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 689",
    "text": "3XX",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "0b20e56e-0184-49f6-9d60-75a11a01c3a2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 93",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "2dee7686-44da-42d1-953a-93330ffc736a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 781",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 14,
    "id": "91525d05-710f-438c-8ade-d11b942f4711"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 1",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 17,
    "id": "6c3a008f-f70e-48b4-ba0b-70eda5699471"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 199",
    "text": "800",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "4f836150-c3c8-415a-9682-d308302e4a60"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 36",
    "text": "百萬",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 47,
    "id": "0e0365b6-47c8-4807-b532-058cb17ecaf7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 923",
    "text": "250",
    "display_minute": 45,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "3ae6d015-ff81-440d-93e7-0198f67ea1ca"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 524",
    "text": "之前找網紅超貴...",
    "display_minute": 46,
    "display_second": 15,
    "id": "25448579-9843-42e9-b518-a0e757ed49a2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 748",
    "text": "找素人要幾萬吧",
    "display_minute": 46,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "18d3fec9-fa66-4130-8550-d42691d28c81"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 36",
    "text": "台灣口音 需要！",
    "display_minute": 46,
    "display_second": 47,
    "id": "9647034f-c45c-4aea-9464-8bcb5b4146f7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 208",
    "text": "！",
    "display_minute": 46,
    "display_second": 58,
    "id": "05d2183c-1092-46b8-979f-6c78a3f47495"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 495",
    "text": "好便宜",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "05643a64-6a5a-4e03-9827-692cdaa442c1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 161",
    "text": "🤯",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 14,
    "id": "ed5e58c6-0bc6-4294-8082-1a83040db5b8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 96",
    "text": "好心動",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "b4d6f005-8921-4feb-9ae6-4100a601de82"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 322",
    "text": "怎麼學",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "ae5e3ec3-1add-47bb-883c-ea66af4e249c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 61",
    "text": "數位垃圾 哈哈",
    "display_minute": 48,
    "display_second": 51,
    "id": "3ae236c6-e5a5-4bef-8436-562e2b46bf38"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 198",
    "text": "偶像",
    "display_minute": 49,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "753f4f21-9d1c-4422-85e0-b7f659db0e7b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 563",
    "text": "一次性",
    "display_minute": 50,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "ac14db22-551d-48b1-9b19-40b352765775"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 157",
    "text": "左",
    "display_minute": 50,
    "display_second": 10,
    "id": "ec859996-9a45-45bd-ba37-39cdbe0cea2d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 154",
    "text": "ＷＯＷＷ",
    "display_minute": 51,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "d16525fa-3178-478f-ab84-5fd169b9cde8"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "幫大家截了剛剛那頁～ https://ad360-assets.hipro.cc/ad-creative-flow/asset-library/file/2026-08/d8397d66-5286-4113-8992-b6426a5d257c-%E6%88%AA%E5%9C%96-2026-08-07-%E6%99%9A%E4%B8%8A7.19.39.jpg",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 21,
    "id": "1ccf1703-e907-4940-9ead-8f2527179ff6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 681",
    "text": "想要自動做圖片做影片的！",
    "display_minute": 53,
    "display_second": 48,
    "id": "f9ef670c-5b09-417e-b79f-51aa55232ca7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 333",
    "text": "心動",
    "display_minute": 57,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "d9d9156e-5db6-4e9e-a8d9-9ba6ec3462ef"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 827",
    "text": "之前我們老闆花了快 30 萬做 CRM 自動導入系統 結果 bug 一堆 找新的工程師來就整個重做 真的就要重花甚至比 40 萬更多的錢 白白花了很多冤枉錢...",
    "display_minute": 58,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "54b22baf-5212-4d25-84b5-1a6d81040e9f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 935",
    "text": "好",
    "display_minute": 61,
    "display_second": 3,
    "id": "b8c63de1-b6a0-4605-8ef8-ebd85f35b5ac"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 741",
    "text": "可是之前請AI想出來的笑話都很糟 老師怎麼解決",
    "display_minute": 62,
    "display_second": 57,
    "id": "6652f95b-c928-4964-a9be-d5c0bc2225bc"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 214",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 19,
    "id": "ac2b1379-4e1e-43d1-8f4d-93ef2e80a1f9"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 191",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "4eb851b5-b1b1-48bb-9813-5b58444e7b67"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 178",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 28,
    "id": "e3a2afaf-58f8-41a2-9e55-49556ffe9825"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 172",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "26f8a010-fa58-4841-9952-8c60ebf5fa40"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 986",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 34,
    "id": "dc80330f-d82d-4b39-a9a5-87d5ffbd9414"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 422",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "d2952830-3419-4090-bbcf-5a4c5f6c4a4f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 589",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 38,
    "id": "957511ea-9212-4e8c-8c36-4718927caf13"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 340",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "1715f027-c8b7-4168-a795-a8ebdba322c6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 91",
    "text": "+2",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 42,
    "id": "98d0c524-3af4-429e-b29f-488093b651ca"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 704",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 46,
    "id": "d7542b0c-59a4-4cea-898b-798890b34929"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 270",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 49,
    "id": "3d9ea079-5e02-4442-bd35-25b6e70f70b5"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 924",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 52,
    "id": "d2f3e715-90d2-44e7-aaaf-052ef3175427"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 27",
    "text": "+33",
    "display_minute": 64,
    "display_second": 57,
    "id": "9873e961-0bea-477c-8e10-a92138e40f57"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 110",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "ac164dc9-c0e9-4f55-a9ad-698c98bc1da0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 513",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 3,
    "id": "b81c352a-ebc9-40ea-bf76-a056d408cc4d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 672",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 5,
    "id": "a63b4ee0-e7d8-4cca-adbe-a925c863eb5e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 545",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "7c963289-6bff-4fcf-af16-2ec188c0a7f8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 371",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 10,
    "id": "be1c89aa-db0c-4d51-99b8-17899e810b0d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 908",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 13,
    "id": "aa319dcd-a352-4ead-ba81-95ce4a1ff65a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 597",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "3c769bd1-7f6c-4cb9-95cb-1d2da40073be"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 448",
    "text": "1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 29,
    "id": "daaa8bec-a30e-4151-bc97-410464405426"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 342",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 65,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "1cc144c2-02bc-4c95-afe2-635f6934c7af"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 90",
    "text": "...",
    "display_minute": 66,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "697617ce-2e3c-4add-9a42-ef74015712a8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 727",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 69,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "25be7ef5-1a17-4446-bbed-d2f2292388f5"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 956",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 69,
    "display_second": 57,
    "id": "a539eca5-80dd-4521-9a25-3f27b05d6232"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 488",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 2,
    "id": "19e01093-79fd-49d4-9f88-b7160463d2d5"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 371",
    "text": "🎉",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "dceb7d14-922f-4f60-95f7-cda27b188e3c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 500",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "0c2efdab-1503-4d3f-9e82-4e7af9ddbd25"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 237",
    "text": "❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 21,
    "id": "8a93c779-df99-4913-bb96-531ee5fcea97"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 200",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 24,
    "id": "20907dec-e485-4f68-bb5d-fc59f2a0649c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 633",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "6b74666f-a354-4dcd-a90e-84c720054392"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 465",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "75cb136e-0f98-478e-b8af-ea2b023dd44f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 721",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 70,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "6a93989d-477c-4623-81f1-830cfd0ae1a2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 54",
    "text": "居然可以這樣用",
    "display_minute": 72,
    "display_second": 17,
    "id": "78a36814-5676-4ebf-86e4-e9e6e9b18ac8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 805",
    "text": "好方便",
    "display_minute": 72,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "a4c45c87-505f-4b4c-a8a6-eb3ab5cff60d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 360",
    "text": "蘇胡～",
    "display_minute": 72,
    "display_second": 50,
    "id": "d10d8ff1-e24b-4cad-8525-4525b131c7ef"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 226",
    "text": "兇",
    "display_minute": 74,
    "display_second": 58,
    "id": "096c3862-ce75-47c2-b7c5-d1aed8c7e7de"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 267",
    "text": "好好玩",
    "display_minute": 75,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "65f0fbfa-5ba4-4855-b13a-227ac3b0c829"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 719",
    "text": "經典笑話ＸＤ",
    "display_minute": 78,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "b6b09a7b-72da-4e4b-bf32-06064e04b2a7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 908",
    "text": "很台灣味啊",
    "display_minute": 78,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "faa14150-4a65-4ffd-ae67-0f27354bb394"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 136",
    "text": "喜歡 Enjoy 哈哈",
    "display_minute": 78,
    "display_second": 58,
    "id": "dee23d01-31e7-4aa8-acb5-f8e471cf3f7d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 743",
    "text": "好ㄔ",
    "display_minute": 81,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "e3d3b019-ec0b-4209-a45c-43ee98ed1f53"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 744",
    "text": "好強",
    "display_minute": 82,
    "display_second": 38,
    "id": "f887a462-2296-4afd-8249-f148d6ac1288"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 31",
    "text": "厲害！",
    "display_minute": 82,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "669df166-4114-4913-8e8a-707b26f2c2a2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 526",
    "text": "👏",
    "display_minute": 82,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "530beb7d-0682-4d3b-aaf2-4871d19cd230"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 186",
    "text": "老師我待會有事 可以先問Line小編 怎麼報名嗎",
    "display_minute": 84,
    "display_second": 47,
    "id": "2b208c43-8d64-4f98-85a4-b77a8c9a9f1f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 489",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 84,
    "display_second": 54,
    "id": "e40afb46-652a-43c9-8d30-36dca09deb9d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 96",
    "text": "厲害！",
    "display_minute": 84,
    "display_second": 55,
    "id": "8bdaabcb-e069-4e3d-87fd-1dde819d9668"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 358",
    "text": "❤️❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 3,
    "id": "5759b446-4f63-47e0-a73a-10f931675f65"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 425",
    "text": "屌",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 5,
    "id": "3d5e1821-0477-45b8-89be-6a65e4452f05"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 509",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "15972c25-a327-40eb-9463-f402b9ea488c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 76",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 10,
    "id": "4c9629ff-e870-483b-820b-adcc56ec7552"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 912",
    "text": "屌",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "2035aca3-93d0-4500-8726-7dda53957990"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 790",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 17,
    "id": "24840cde-5203-4405-a143-182eb6e82ea4"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 329",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "ddb8653e-9423-4ded-a147-236e84aed97c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 722",
    "text": "屌XD",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "21b54cbb-220f-424c-ba65-1f477aae618a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 944",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "94ab12f6-5e99-4ff1-a53e-2c911e580475"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 656",
    "text": "超級厲害",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 32,
    "id": "f081d32b-aaad-4af3-9d0a-a7bf1b561905"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 923",
    "text": "❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️",
    "display_minute": 85,
    "display_second": 46,
    "id": "a995f6a9-f209-4b84-a7df-053f08625cc7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 123",
    "text": "屌",
    "display_minute": 86,
    "display_second": 2,
    "id": "32af024a-49bd-4969-8b9c-e7d84216752b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 372",
    "text": "屌",
    "display_minute": 86,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "4964d4f3-8c2f-4d86-a870-f4be83db6afe"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 252",
    "text": "❤️",
    "display_minute": 87,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "ba372b62-b632-4506-965b-2604bb357627"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 649",
    "text": "媒體",
    "display_minute": 89,
    "display_second": 29,
    "id": "d64fbf88-6cfd-4a13-902a-efbdc5645c70"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 62",
    "text": "怎麼報名",
    "display_minute": 89,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "846b96ed-c84a-4bfa-8d6d-51d23151bbae"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 243",
    "text": "是線上課還是實體課",
    "display_minute": 90,
    "display_second": 24,
    "id": "9516d7e2-4422-4a9e-b30d-94021b0429e7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 453",
    "text": "用心推+1",
    "display_minute": 91,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "7c460a42-6f80-499c-b92e-3752a652c8e7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 886",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "9ab8a6c2-16b1-4335-bf1e-d35d5d8e3c3e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 175",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "c5cda5c5-c77a-43f3-b5a5-e962b9f668bb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 315",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 24,
    "id": "7cde057c-1a40-485e-9702-34deb5a8804f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 328",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "7fc60659-412a-48c7-aadf-f0c99346fe60"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 667",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "fe997586-4c1c-45e4-aa32-04a397d51255"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 557",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 30,
    "id": "56828fae-161b-4681-aad0-a986d1199bfd"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 312",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 32,
    "id": "a86bf613-7dde-4c8b-82ea-ca02caca5e1f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 520",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "138e6d33-9d76-4cfb-a581-f08764fc4dc2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 691",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "d7324d0b-e711-4043-9e0a-33eca1bda12b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 359",
    "text": "+1+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "9f8b26bc-d2d9-4d2c-9813-e32d875ec4b3"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 974",
    "text": "+111",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 45,
    "id": "e57a422c-3ab9-4790-bd0d-39836ca3d9c9"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 565",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 48,
    "id": "9c0f2d13-c06f-42c6-b2fd-40454a4f73b0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 769",
    "text": "+100",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 57,
    "id": "97fceaa6-8dd7-4caa-a32d-022713a2053f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 667",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 93,
    "display_second": 58,
    "id": "3f59b488-2faa-45ed-a08c-13a3b748c12f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 621",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "f942a638-d56d-4453-856c-cd6d40591452"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 29",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "82b0e726-2e5f-4a15-b103-cf889e0a52bb"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 341",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 5,
    "id": "44d45c9d-a6ce-4b0b-bf91-582f78eac086"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 991",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "55ada0c3-8318-40df-87b3-ea60e4beb654"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 141",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 10,
    "id": "cfc44281-57dd-4385-8bf5-06b605c4bc6d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 353",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "454b8917-027f-48b9-9c0b-06e3d2566818"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 979",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 13,
    "id": "9578dfa5-06ba-4d67-8f8d-97d82ffbe42b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 412",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 15,
    "id": "93518b00-d8e5-4724-b21c-776a99779286"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 990",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "727aae59-1f6f-4900-94c0-5f1e16067c19"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 796",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 94,
    "display_second": 23,
    "id": "ec0d6735-4c2f-43b8-9080-32ae60a4210e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 636",
    "text": "我信用卡準備好了",
    "display_minute": 96,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "9e112c31-5b3f-4057-bb23-bc92e676fcc6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 408",
    "text": "喜歡",
    "display_minute": 97,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "7c1d1981-d8c4-4707-a457-e209f6e4cf3b"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 390",
    "text": "零經驗+1",
    "display_minute": 97,
    "display_second": 46,
    "id": "adafa019-963a-48b4-8c3d-d5e1078338db"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 1",
    "text": "有優惠嗎",
    "display_minute": 98,
    "display_second": 40,
    "id": "4b71a3fb-defb-4f95-9ec1-d7cb27638f3c"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 167",
    "text": "怎麼下單",
    "display_minute": 99,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "e4f0357c-2946-4630-8f78-4ed47ee9bc14"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 405",
    "text": "老師我有私訊Line 要打統編",
    "display_minute": 100,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "1d79d3dd-1f29-400d-931f-be254622722a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 170",
    "text": "好",
    "display_minute": 101,
    "display_second": 24,
    "id": "b19548f2-587f-4c46-aa4e-f1816c282549"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 773",
    "text": "BB384",
    "display_minute": 102,
    "display_second": 24,
    "id": "0bf890ab-1823-4e87-b929-e0f92787a18d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 296",
    "text": "BB384",
    "display_minute": 102,
    "display_second": 28,
    "id": "0b60d2d1-4d08-43c2-a0fd-f1a657dd9d18"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 903",
    "text": "BB384",
    "display_minute": 102,
    "display_second": 39,
    "id": "5086c975-6bc3-4d9e-8264-bb7d9205cfb6"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "掃 Qrcode 或點這個連結都可以歐！\nhttps://all.99agent.app/q/p/BAAAAS",
    "display_minute": 102,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "15e4525c-bf11-406a-ba09-d79c0d11e560"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 141",
    "text": "我下單了",
    "display_minute": 104,
    "display_second": 55,
    "id": "cf9690b4-cd07-439f-86d1-fe3b8bb5d6c0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 112",
    "text": "國泰可以分幾期",
    "display_minute": 105,
    "display_second": 23,
    "id": "6e1fb46d-b625-4fcb-9f8f-96783f124d39"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "同學可以在Line留言 我幫大家處理歐",
    "display_minute": 106,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "3f5f11f5-f657-4b62-99cb-3b24a0c14a0a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 540",
    "text": "已下單",
    "display_minute": 107,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "9ca8070a-306e-4e1a-ba67-f6245bce88b4"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 809",
    "text": "家裡網路慢 好塞QQ",
    "display_minute": 108,
    "display_second": 56,
    "id": "b008d2e1-22a4-4abd-8c78-303fab4e57c2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 480",
    "text": "搶到了！",
    "display_minute": 109,
    "display_second": 14,
    "id": "502949d1-d157-4b51-a6da-1b93ded2ac97"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 665",
    "text": "+1",
    "display_minute": 109,
    "display_second": 49,
    "id": "95064d6d-c075-48cb-97af-9243a1251aff"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 149",
    "text": "期待上課^^",
    "display_minute": 110,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "d5defae6-b665-426a-9dfb-7614ca82a14e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 684",
    "text": "預約",
    "display_minute": 110,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "24a26baa-722f-461e-9ff6-c4abb042500d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 582",
    "text": "預約",
    "display_minute": 110,
    "display_second": 51,
    "id": "ca548fdc-17dd-4a08-8af2-e98069b3db44"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "同學在Line上面打預約歐",
    "display_minute": 111,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "e7d5f043-6a1c-4f90-8b7b-c19339e27b92"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 846",
    "text": "已私 想問無卡的問題",
    "display_minute": 112,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "2694d4d0-c167-44eb-a43f-8ad0266e2de0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 745",
    "text": "已下單！",
    "display_minute": 112,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "89296464-7453-48ba-813d-83dedd50d3a4"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 3",
    "text": "謝謝老師",
    "display_minute": 112,
    "display_second": 37,
    "id": "7c14518d-f6e6-40a8-b331-9dccaab34945"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 993",
    "text": "88",
    "display_minute": 112,
    "display_second": 46,
    "id": "111e88b3-2529-475d-b7a4-667a8b8723e6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 323",
    "text": "謝！",
    "display_minute": 112,
    "display_second": 51,
    "id": "d9ae040c-0ff0-4e01-915e-5c9867c25812"
  }
]
完整陣列 6 AI First 完整 chatMessages 陣列（59 則） 
[
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "嗨 大家記得在Line上面打上簽到，待會留言我們都在Line上面留會有AI做遊戲互動歐！",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 0,
    "id": "1783934253172"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 952",
    "text": "嗨！",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "5b19a253-0da1-453c-a5ed-d8c54406b3c8"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "Wade老師好",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "fd3f1d82-68e2-4908-933d-b4112cf27781"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 304",
    "text": "hi",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 26,
    "id": "33d37360-de80-426e-ab4f-8f4c53f422e8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 401",
    "text": "剛吃飽",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "2347331e-89ce-444e-8888-a543f2fca300"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 290",
    "text": "321",
    "display_minute": 0,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "4ea60ef4-4090-4d40-a053-3bd7b4df80f1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 359",
    "text": "Hi 偉哥",
    "display_minute": 1,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "b5f33950-85de-460b-a53c-ee7f541853c1"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 717",
    "text": "期待🤩",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "c277ea58-819b-409e-9f7b-2f4975971dcc"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 577",
    "text": "不行 我要留下",
    "display_minute": 2,
    "display_second": 53,
    "id": "ec0caa97-ec1c-4175-bdf1-1377a25edc49"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "提醒！大家記得留到最後～～～有驚喜",
    "display_minute": 3,
    "display_second": 19,
    "id": "755aa4e0-12e3-428e-a5d6-426d72298e0d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 415",
    "text": "想要諮詢",
    "display_minute": 4,
    "display_second": 23,
    "id": "2b9488cf-a1f0-4fb8-bd09-b3f012ca63ad"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 843",
    "text": "好酷",
    "display_minute": 5,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "b8ba4e89-ad13-4b29-a5f6-3b1fde9a3f6f"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 919",
    "text": "路上好多工程師....",
    "display_minute": 8,
    "display_second": 2,
    "id": "83eeef94-fa31-410b-9f57-e2ace18b26f2"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 469",
    "text": "天啊🤯",
    "display_minute": 9,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "e564b352-04fa-47aa-8fec-4334d2b6d897"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 654",
    "text": "被取代了嗎？",
    "display_minute": 9,
    "display_second": 37,
    "id": "a37d2f67-7940-45d7-9e09-d7300cac4ce0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 682",
    "text": "我目前只會問問題",
    "display_minute": 10,
    "display_second": 50,
    "id": "061bcaeb-c7ec-4d38-93e8-7d0f8ecef694"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 525",
    "text": "有",
    "display_minute": 11,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "f5e6c1b7-1a78-4406-8399-66d7b46d6d73"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 378",
    "text": "有",
    "display_minute": 11,
    "display_second": 35,
    "id": "684790d1-7832-41d2-9f7c-e2558f5664dd"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 506",
    "text": "有",
    "display_minute": 11,
    "display_second": 37,
    "id": "445632ff-7fdc-413d-b866-d94d8b63c8ea"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "在Line喔！",
    "display_minute": 11,
    "display_second": 50,
    "id": "eb3736a5-ebad-4741-bc04-745821bdfc23"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 547",
    "text": "我要",
    "display_minute": 12,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "cf632fe6-16eb-4853-bcea-210f0fa08175"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 456",
    "text": "我ㄧㄠ",
    "display_minute": 13,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "b3970df2-2991-4990-af8d-e34eedf018c0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 690",
    "text": "重新洗牌的機會",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "4c503659-86b5-402e-8f06-72cb291d8440"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 296",
    "text": "我要",
    "display_minute": 14,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "f7f48ec2-f8b8-4fee-bef8-edf93f298a47"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 573",
    "text": "需要私訊分流",
    "display_minute": 15,
    "display_second": 57,
    "id": "3607343c-6951-4522-b55a-cc7d78ce58a7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 420",
    "text": "😮😮😮",
    "display_minute": 16,
    "display_second": 34,
    "id": "defd922d-9b21-4a22-abc4-de4e8ee44c1e"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "這是我們來自各行各業的學生～",
    "display_minute": 18,
    "display_second": 42,
    "id": "c5b4e965-932d-47aa-b3f8-74039db98e22"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 127",
    "text": "這也可以自己做？",
    "display_minute": 18,
    "display_second": 55,
    "id": "a13a28f8-6165-4404-9b72-a5c99042436d"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 776",
    "text": "有想法的人",
    "display_minute": 21,
    "display_second": 16,
    "id": "bd5e1f2b-bf9a-4d1e-a068-6c616b80dbb9"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 707",
    "text": "讚攢!!!!",
    "display_minute": 22,
    "display_second": 23,
    "id": "0b8ca785-b16d-4581-8bf0-85ff2b355a74"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 950",
    "text": "是純線上的嗎？",
    "display_minute": 24,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "4c0b562f-6196-41f9-ae1a-72a58d11f7bd"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 345",
    "text": "好酷喔0w0",
    "display_minute": 24,
    "display_second": 48,
    "id": "daf61685-d49f-4a94-ad4c-9cdba7931a46"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 192",
    "text": "想問老師有推薦要訂閱哪些工具嗎？",
    "display_minute": 26,
    "display_second": 11,
    "id": "caafe4e7-ee05-4f83-b9c5-6ff42ac26864"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 664",
    "text": "省錢省人力👍",
    "display_minute": 27,
    "display_second": 48,
    "id": "0b861d2c-1b8b-49bc-8630-c4c8427b58f7"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 979",
    "text": "我有信！心！可！以！",
    "display_minute": 29,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "4643af2f-6035-4124-bdd5-3f49a703cc84"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 781",
    "text": "我要我要！！！預約",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 15,
    "id": "e957f3e6-5b85-4b26-a76d-2866a62032b6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 775",
    "text": "預約",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "433080d3-ef3a-4d5a-ad32-52e5cc32e1f9"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 198",
    "text": "預約",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 31,
    "id": "3d78842c-01a3-4541-99d6-59d49b2b6fb3"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "大家記得是在LINE上喔！！！！打[預約]",
    "display_minute": 30,
    "display_second": 59,
    "id": "b8c97d92-52b1-46cc-b8ed-590fe88ddfcb"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "剩下2位囉！",
    "display_minute": 31,
    "display_second": 18,
    "id": "17c46591-1b0b-4727-8001-afc39d082896"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "額滿！謝謝大家～",
    "display_minute": 31,
    "display_second": 41,
    "id": "1e6c8914-0f9d-4190-9079-455e37dffe37"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 160",
    "text": "請問要做到這樣，要重買電腦嗎？",
    "display_minute": 34,
    "display_second": 44,
    "id": "e62b68c1-31da-44c6-ad17-427252f0bb84"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 639",
    "text": "有興趣",
    "display_minute": 37,
    "display_second": 20,
    "id": "17ea8ac6-cd33-459b-90e7-c2015b0fde6e"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 300",
    "text": "聽起來還蠻完整的",
    "display_minute": 40,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "98b04741-9c78-4df1-b42f-c5de3ab6a570"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 682",
    "text": "所以說課程會送這些？",
    "display_minute": 41,
    "display_second": 14,
    "id": "925ab554-5fe6-492c-9b17-5377fbe7ae09"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 528",
    "text": "！？",
    "display_minute": 43,
    "display_second": 4,
    "id": "df367b84-e3ac-4a3a-a7ad-797a7db855b8"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 514",
    "text": "差好多",
    "display_minute": 43,
    "display_second": 7,
    "id": "16a66b8e-25eb-423d-97a0-a6af8b303781"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 356",
    "text": "😮",
    "display_minute": 43,
    "display_second": 22,
    "id": "b0fec706-0404-4c74-a930-53483b2a3e98"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 548",
    "text": "已打",
    "display_minute": 46,
    "display_second": 25,
    "id": "2da6a740-357f-4430-a324-83fa2306bae8"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "LINE上輸入[666]！",
    "display_minute": 46,
    "display_second": 43,
    "id": "c44ec346-ebe0-4699-b4c1-6093412426a8"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "恭喜第一位同學：陳O芳！",
    "display_minute": 47,
    "display_second": 6,
    "id": "2d7c6e25-0f2a-4377-8db4-8902c1365332"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "張O琳 感謝加入～",
    "display_minute": 48,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "3db0f002-d6f6-4c6e-948c-03687e01fdfe"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 955",
    "text": "已購買！係謝老師",
    "display_minute": 49,
    "display_second": 2,
    "id": "4991556d-5c3f-416f-b8f4-4a814060929a"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "林Ｏ宜 感謝加入～",
    "display_minute": 49,
    "display_second": 33,
    "id": "d5e4d905-40fb-41ec-abe1-54dcc91265d0"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 645",
    "text": "感謝回答",
    "display_minute": 51,
    "display_second": 1,
    "id": "7d2d38ea-dfb9-4935-bb2d-8f0f92542d4c"
  },
  {
    "username": "助教",
    "text": "最後3位！",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 12,
    "id": "011d74e2-8fe7-415c-8a7d-95d14eb4c649"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 853",
    "text": "謝謝老師",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 27,
    "id": "a66c32f1-2256-423f-a341-31418044b3d6"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 534",
    "text": "謝謝!!!!!!!",
    "display_minute": 52,
    "display_second": 36,
    "id": "7d8eecb2-272c-4cf1-a602-0b850183283a"
  },
  {
    "username": "Guest 577",
    "text": "謝謝老師~",
    "display_minute": 53,
    "display_second": 8,
    "id": "e028bab5-906d-4d81-9051-b46313c2d040"
  }
]
設定證據 P25 ainext 原始預排訊息節選 
                            {
  "總數": 83,
  "節選": [
    {
      "username": "Guest 916",
      "text": "+1",
      "display_minute": 0,
      "display_second": 16,
      "id": "0ede5a2d-f33a-46dd-8ba9-584c13576c3e"
    },
    {
      "username": "Guest 66",
      "text": "+1",
      "display_minute": 0,
      "display_second": 18,
      "id": "9a2e0fe3-6a5c-4c12-8d98-de62e6f23742"
    },
    {
      "username": "Guest 861",
      "text": "+1",
      "display_minute": 0,
      "display_second": 22,
      "id": "17b51998-0061-4f8c-acee-30362c5caf9d"
    },
    {
      "username": "助教",
      "text": "第一位同學下單囉！陳O瑜",
      "display_minute": 53,
      "display_second": 26,
      "id": "ace1993d-d2d0-4c8e-a959-06e4654228c2"
    },
    {
      "username": "助教",
      "text": "同學陸續下單中！！",
      "display_minute": 54,
      "display_second": 22,
      "id": "e33a0274-f109-444c-9ba9-392af1616983"
    }
  ]
}
設定證據 P26 n8n 原始預排訊息節選 
                            {
  "總數": 225,
  "節選": [
    {
      "username": "Guest 687",
      "text": "嗨嗨",
      "display_minute": 0,
      "display_second": 4,
      "id": "a5aab8ff-7e13-4818-8f84-1249c9b351da"
    },
    {
      "username": "Guest 4",
      "text": "嗨",
      "display_minute": 5,
      "display_second": 1,
      "id": "e7b97a93-5d0c-4914-b52f-17e62733cfce"
    },
    {
      "username": "Guest 974",
      "text": "老師好！",
      "display_minute": 5,
      "display_second": 6,
      "id": "74e7fd49-7b39-4182-8fd9-199f871bdad1"
    },
    {
      "username": "Guest 636",
      "text": "我信用卡準備好了",
      "display_minute": 96,
      "display_second": 26,
      "id": "9e112c31-5b3f-4057-bb23-bc92e676fcc6"
    },
    {
      "username": "Guest 167",
      "text": "怎麼下單",
      "display_minute": 99,
      "display_second": 31,
      "id": "e4f0357c-2946-4630-8f78-4ed47ee9bc14"
    }
  ]
}
L4程式／保存畫面可確認

程式替本頁訪客編號時會避開預排留言使用的號碼

程式掃描頁面腳本裡的 Guest 數字，建立保留清單；從 1～999 尚未用到的號碼選一個給本頁使用者，並存入 sessionStorage。若號碼已用滿，再從 1000 起找空號。這項邏輯會避免本頁分配的編號與預排留言編號重複。原始註解使用「模擬留言」「真實觀眾」等字眼。

原始碼證據 P27 蒐集腳本暱稱、排除後再給本頁觀眾 
 518    function collectSimulatedGuestNumbers() {
 519      var reserved = Object.create(null);
 520  
 521      Array.prototype.forEach.call(document.scripts, function (script) {
 522        var source = script.src ? "" : String(script.textContent || "");
 523        var matches = source.match(/\bGuest\s+\d+\b/gi) || [];
 524  
 525        // WebinarKit 的模擬留言資料集中在同一段腳本；單一 Guest 則是本頁真實觀眾名稱。
 526        if (matches.length < 2) {
 527          return;
 528        }
 529  
 530        matches.forEach(function (value) {
 531          var numberMatch = value.match(/\d+/);
 532          if (numberMatch) {
 533            reserved[Number(numberMatch[0])] = true;
 534          }
 535        });
 536      });
 537  
 538      return reserved;
 539    }
 540  
 541    function chooseAvailableRealGuestNumber(reserved) {
 542      var available = [];
 543      var number;
 544  
 545      for (number = 1; number <= 999; number += 1) {
 546        if (!reserved[number]) {
 547          available.push(number);
 548        }
 549      }
 550  
 551      if (!available.length) {
 552        // 1～999 全被模擬留言使用時，改從四位數開始找第一個空號。

··· 中間省略 ···

 590    function ensureRealViewerGuestNumber() {
 591      if (realViewerGuestNumberChecked || typeof window.username !== "string") {
 592        return;
 593      }
 594  
 595      var currentMatch = window.username.match(/^Guest\s+(\d+)$/i);
 596      if (!currentMatch) {
 597        realViewerGuestNumberChecked = true;
 598        return;
 599      }
 600  
 601      var reserved = collectSimulatedGuestNumbers();
 602      if (!Object.keys(reserved).length) {
 603        return;
 604      }
 605  
 606      // 每位真實觀眾都從模擬留言未使用的號碼中取號；同一瀏覽器場次會沿用已選號碼。
 607      window.username =
 608        "Guest " + String(chooseAvailableRealGuestNumber(reserved));
 609  
 610      realViewerGuestNumberChecked = true;
L5有證據，結論有範圍

保存版本含 Socket.IO 發送程式與接收端顯示限制

送出處理器呼叫 Socket.IO 的 socket.emit('chat_message', …)。接收處理器在保存版本只將管理員或「與本頁使用者 ID 相同」的訊息加入畫面；其他一般觀眾訊息不會走入這個顯示分支。預排訊息則直接呼叫顯示函式，走另一條路徑。

因此程式設計支持「自己的訊息可能出現，其他一般觀眾不會看到」的結果。不過使用者先前發送 123 的 Network 畫面沒有顯示 WebSocket 連線或聊天封包，只有畫面出現文字；尚不能寫成那一次訊息已成功送達伺服器。

原始碼證據 P28 Socket 發送程式 
   9  var send_chat_message_button = document.getElementById('send_chat_message_button');
  10  
  11  if (send_chat_message_button) {
  12    send_chat_message_button.onclick = send;
  13  }
  14  
  15  var chat_message = document.getElementById('chat_message');
  16  
  17  if (chat_message) {
  18    chat_message.addEventListener('keypress', function(event) {
  19      if (event.key === 'Enter') {
  20        event.preventDefault();
  21        send();
  22      }
  23    });
  24  }
  25  
  26  function send() {
  27    let message = $('#chat_message').val();
  28  
  29    if (message) {
  30      socket.emit('chat_message', JSON.stringify({
  31        id: `[本頁使用者ID]`,
  32        username: username,
  33        email: registrant_email,
  34        event_date: event_timestamp,
  35        messageID: Date.now(),
  36        message: message
  37      }));
  38  
  39      $('#chat_message').val('');
  40  
  41      engaged_in_event_chat = true;
  42    }
原始碼證據 P29 接收後僅顯示管理員或本人；初始化 WebSocket 
  64    socket.on('chat_message', function(msg) {
  65      var item = JSON.parse(msg);
  66  
  67      if (false) {
  68        addMessageUtility(item);
  69      } else {
  70        if (item.is_admin || `[本頁使用者ID]` === item.id) {
  71          addMessageUtility(item);
  72        }
  73      }
  74    });

··· 中間省略 ···

  83  function initialize_socket() {
  84    if (socket) {
  85      socket.disconnect();
  86    }
  87  
  88    socket = io(window.location.origin, {
  89      query: 'r_var=' + `6adc6af93d15a12d0688e773`,
  90      transports: ['websocket']
  91    });
  92  
  93    initialize_socket_events();
  94  
  95    socket.emit('username', JSON.stringify({
  96      id: `[本頁使用者ID]`,
  97      username: username,
  98      privilege: 'attendee',
  99      message: `已加入聊天室` ? `已加入聊天室` : 'has joined the chat'
 100    }));
 101  }
 102  
 103  initialize_socket();
L6程式／保存畫面可確認

部分播放室只是把聊天輸入列隱藏

ADragon、SalesKing、AppIPO 保存樣本設定 hideViewerChatInput: true，用 CSS 隱藏輸入列並在原聊天容器插入資訊公告。AI-NEXT、n8n、AI First 的保存樣本則為 false。看不到輸入框不能推成網站沒有聊天室功能。

ADragon 本次匿名入口

本次只顯示公告、輸入列被隱藏；聊天連線與收送程式仍存在。此圖不能否定 10/25 19:00 場次有聊天室。

使用者提供的 10/25 ADragon 畫面

聊天室與輸入列清楚可見。日期依使用者陳述；單張截圖不能判定訊息是否即時送出。

原始碼證據 P30 隱藏輸入列的設定與 CSS 
  25  
  26      // ===== 資訊分頁 =====
  27      hideViewerChatInput: true,
  28      pinnedMessages: [
  29        {
  30          text: "歡迎來到直播！重要資訊會統一放在這邊，推薦用電腦觀看直播，比較不會有播放問題"
  31        },
  32        {
  33          text: "進來直播，請記得在Line上面留言「簽到」，待會重要的互動都在Line上面留言，會有AI回覆客製化的體驗歐！",
  34          url: "",
  35          linkText: "查看詳情"

··· 中間省略 ···

 103      style.id = "wk-audience-style";
 104      style.textContent =
 105        (CONFIG.hideViewerChatInput
 106          ? "#messagerow{display:none!important;}" +
 107            ".webinarkit-chat-emoji-popover{display:none!important;}"
 108          : "") +
 109        "body.wk-mobile-browser-gated{overflow:hidden!important;touch-action:none!important;}" +
05

新聞外觀與課程背書

沿著 LINE、新聞頁、搜尋結果與舊活動脈絡，檢查背書從何而來。

N1使用者提供的觀察

LINE 的「相關報導」把課程引到一個新聞外觀網站

使用者提供的 AI Plus 官方帳號截圖顯示「相關報導」按鈕；其操作紀錄指出點擊後開啟 daynews.app。後續截圖顯示站名「今日時報」、新聞分類、編輯台與日期，並刊載與 AI Plus 講師及團隊規模有關的文章。

這一連串素材能呈現課程導流與新聞式背書的路徑。單張 LINE 截圖本身不能證明按鈕的實際 href；這段跳轉關係的來源是使用者的操作敘述。

AI Plus LINE 帳號與「相關報導」按鈕

使用者提供，部分資訊已由提供者塗除。

開啟後的今日時報與 daynews.app

新聞外觀、站名、網址與文章標題可見。

N2截圖可確認

Google 搜尋結果第一頁未看到 daynews.app

使用者提供的 Google 搜尋截圖中，搜尋結果第一頁沒有出現 daynews.app。

Google 搜尋結果第一頁

畫面中沒有出現 daynews.app。

N3有證據，結論有範圍

新聞照片指向 Intel 活動脈絡，不能拿來證明文中業績

使用者以圖搜圖的截圖指向 Intel《AI PC 創作新世代》相關報導。Intel 官方資料可獨立確認活動在 2024/3/14～3/17 舉辦，並列出六指淵等受邀創作者。這支持「照片有歷史活動脈絡」的查核方向。

目前尚未完成這張照片與 2024 原始照片的逐一比對，所以報告不把以圖搜圖結果寫成已確認的同張原圖。照片本身也不能證明文章中的客戶數與營收；這些數字需另以營運資料核實。

·

新聞中的人物照片

人物站在 Intel Core Ultra 背板前；截圖不能證明文章的商業數字。

使用者的以圖搜圖結果

結果指向 2024 Intel 活動相關報導，仍應找到原始照片完成核對。

N4仍待核實

今日時報的獨立性與文章數字仍待外部證實

使用者提供的操作紀錄顯示，課程帳號的「相關報導」按鈕導向 daynews.app 一篇採新聞版型的文章。文章以編輯台名義發布，提及 5 人團隊、60 多名包月客戶及單月約 300 萬元營收；本次未取得可供讀者獨立重算的原始營運資料。網站設有關於、編輯與來源政策頁，但這些頁面本身不能核實文章數字。現有資料不足以確認文章是否經獨立採訪、網站與課程方有無利益關係，以及數字由誰提供、如何查核。

設定證據 P31 新聞查核來源與限度 
{
  "文章URL": "https://daynews.app/investment/blog/2026-08-14/ai-freelance-team-scaling-sixfinger-yuan",
  "查核日": "2026-11-02",
  "獨立確認": "Intel於2024/3/14~3/17舉辦AI PC創作新世代活動",
  "未完成": "照片逐一比對、網站法律主體與課程方關係、營運數字原始文件"
}

圖片使用相對路徑載入；離線檢視時請將本 HTML 與 report-images 資料夾放在一起。互動程式內嵌於本頁。報告依保存版本描述可觀察現象，不替未取得的後台紀錄作推論。

放大的圖證